The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد
محمد ابراهيم بدران, . (2024). The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد. EKB Journal Management System, 36(45), 948-985. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2024.283240.1427
دعاء محمد ابراهيم بدران. "The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد". EKB Journal Management System, 36, 45, 2024, 948-985. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2024.283240.1427
محمد ابراهيم بدران, . (2024). 'The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد', EKB Journal Management System, 36(45), pp. 948-985. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2024.283240.1427
محمد ابراهيم بدران, . The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد. EKB Journal Management System, 2024; 36(45): 948-985. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2024.283240.1427

The Subject Of Lawsuit Administrative Contracts Conflicts That Can Be Adjudicated Before The Competent Authorities In The Saudi Law. Analytical Study In Light Of The New Governmental Competitions And Purchases System دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي دراسة تحليلية في ضوء نظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد

مجلة البحوث الفقهية والقانونية
Volume 36, Issue 45, April 2024, Page 948-985  XML PDF (871.92 K)
Document Type: المقالة الأصلية
DOI: 10.21608/jlr.2024.283240.1427
View on SCiNiTO View on SCiNiTO
Author
دعاء محمد ابراهيم بدران email
جامعة تبوک- کلية الشريعة والقانون
Abstract
The study addressed the subject of lawsuits related to administrative contract disputes that can be adjudicated before specialized authorities in the Saudi legal system, within the framework of an analytical study concerning the new governmental competitions and procurement system. The aim of this study is to shed light on the objective conditions required to initiate and settle lawsuits related to administrative contracts before specialized judicial authorities, in accordance with Saudi law. Despite the diverse nature of disputes concerning administrative contracts regarding their validity or effects, the National Transformation Program, launched as part of Saudi Arabia's vision, aims to improve governmental operations and establish a legal framework aligned with that vision. This study also highlights the new regulations and systems related to governmental competitions and procurement, which were established according to Royal Decree No. (M/128) dated 13/11/1440 AH. This decree established several committees and councils tasked with resolving disputes related to administrative contracts, exclusively dealing with specific subject matters, whether in administrative courts or quasi-judicial committees endowed with judicial jurisdiction. It's worth mentioning that these committees do not overlap with the jurisdiction areas of administrative courts, and the subject matter they address remains limited, not constituting a strict administrative judiciary body in the traditional sense.
 تناولت الدراسة موضوع دعاوى منازعات العقود الإدارية التي يمكن فصلها أمام الجهات المختصة في النظام السعودي، وذلك في إطار دراسة تحليلية تتعلق بنظام المنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية الجديد. وتهدف هذه الدراسة إلى تسليط الضوء على الشروط الموضوعية المطلوبة لبدء وتسوية الدعاوى المتعلقة بالعقود الإدارية أمام السلطات القضائية المتخصصة، وذلك وفقاً للقانون السعودي. على الرغم من تنوع الخلافات المتعلقة بالعقود الإدارية فيما يتعلق بصحتها أو تأثيراتها، إلا أن برنامج التحول الوطني، الذي تم إطلاقه ضمن رؤية المملكة العربية السعودية، يهدف إلى تحسين العمليات الحكومية ووضع إطار قانوني يتماشى مع تلك الرؤية. وتأتي هذه الدراسة لتسليط الضوء على اللوائح والأنظمة الجديدة المتعلقة بالمنافسات والمشتريات الحكومية، والتي جاءت وفقاً للمرسوم الملكي رقم (م/128) بتاريخ 13/11/1440 هـ. وقد أنشأ هذا المرسوم العديد من اللجان والمجالس المكلفة بفض النزاعات المتعلقة بالعقود الإدارية، والتي تعمل حصراً في التعامل مع الدعاوى ذات الموضوعات المحددة، سواء كانت في المحكمة الإدارية أو اللجان القضائية الشبه قضائية، والتي تتمتع بالاختصاص القضائي. يجدر بالذكر أن هذه اللجان لا تتداخل مع مجالات اختصاص المحكمة الإدارية، ويظل الموضوع الذي تتناوله محدودًا، ولا تشكل جهة قضائية إدارية صارمة في المعنى التقليدي.
Keywords
الدعوى الإدارية; منازعات العقود الإدارية; القانون السعودي; Administrative Lawsuit؛ Administrative Contract Disputes؛ Saudi Law
References
  • Al-Kabir, Muhammad bin Ali bin admire. (2021). The principle of equality in administrative contracts: a study in the light of the Saudi procurement and competition system. Jouf University Journal for Human Sciences, Volume 11
  • Abu Aqil, Aladdin Muhammad Sayed Muhammad. (2021). The legal basis for the financial rebalancing of the administrative contract: the liberalization of the exchange rate as a model. King Abdulaziz University Journal - Economics and Management, Vol. 35.
  • Al-Shaibani, Munir. (2016). Disputes related to administrative contracts: a study in Libyan law. Al-Manara Journal for Legal and Administrative Studies, 13th
  • Al-Shaddadi, Abdul Latif. (2020). The concept of modification in administrative contracts. Moroccan Journal of Local Administration and Development, Volume 155.
  • Al-Shahrani, Abdulilah Bin Saeed Ahmed. (2018). "Special Jurisdiction of Administrative Judiciary in Saudi Arabia Compared to Islamic Jurisprudence." Law and Business Journal, No. 13.أعلى النموذجأسفل النموذج
 

  • AL-SOFANI, D. A. K. A. (2021) The Role of the Administrative judge in In Financial Rebalancing the Administrative Contract.‏ Volume 7.
  • Alzaher, Khaled Khalil (2009) Administrative Judiciary in the Board of Grievances, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia - Library of Law and Economy - Riyadh.
  • Al-Jarbou, A. M. (2011). The Saudi Board of Grievances: Development and New Reforms. Arab Law Quarterly, 25(2).
  • Aljarbou, Ayoub bin Mansour, (2017) Quasi-Judicial Committees in Saudi Law (An analytical study in light of the regular texts and the provisions of the Board of Grievances), first edition
  • Alaoui, Muhammad. (2011). Jurisdiction of the annulment judiciary in administrative contract disputes. Moroccan Journal of Local Administration and Development, Volume101.
  • Alborini, Omar bin Abd Elrahman, (2013) Administrative Decisions that are Separable from the Contract and the Oversight of judiciary on them, Lows Journal, Kuwait, tome13, Number 1, March / Jumada Al-Awwal.
  • - Al-Kahlawi, Rajab Muhammad (2019)، Administrative Contracts, A Comparative Study in the Light of the Saudi Procurement and Competition System, 1st Edition, Dar Al-Shukri,. Vol 3.
  • Altahrawi, (Hanani (2017) who calls it “Economic Risks” in his book Saudi Administrative Law, the second book, first edition.
  • Asseemi, Abdullah Nader. (2018). "Formal Reasons for Dismissing Administrative Lawsuits under the New Saudi Grievance Board System." University of Sharjah Journal of Legal Sciences, Vol. 15, No. 2.
  • . Fahd Ibrahim Aldowayan, (2014) "development of applying the contingent circumstance theory in the Saudi Administrative and Judiciary System, King Saud Journal, tome 26, number 1.
  • Fikri, Fathi (2004) Alwajeez in the annulment lawsuit according to the provisions of the judiciary, Nass Printing Company.
  • Hama, Z. R., & Rasheed, A. K. M. (2021). The competence of the full jurisdiction to settle administrative contracts disputes. Journal of University of Human Development, 7(1).
  • Hassan Almoanis (2020), Administrative Disputes in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, 2nd Edition.
  • Hamada Abd Elrazek Hamada (1442), Mediator in Administrative Contracts in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, An Applied Analytical Study, first edition
  • Jaafar, Anas, (2007) Administrative Contracts, Arab Renaissance House, fourth edition, vol. 24.
  • Khalifa Abd Alaziz Abd Elmoneim (2004), General Foundations of Administrative Contracts.
  • Khater, Sherif Youssef, (2009) Principles of Administrative Law, a comparative study, Dar Alnahda Alarabiya.
 

  • L'Aqoun, Afaf, and Rita, Walid. (2021). The specificity of administrative dispute: public procurement disputes in Algeria as a model. Journal of Judicial Jurisprudence, Volume 13, Special Issue.
  • Mabkhouta, Ahmed, and Ali, Sharmat Sayed. (2020). Recent economic developments and reorganization of the contractual aspect of administrative contracts. Annals of the University of Algiers 1, Volume 34, Volume 1.
  • Muslim, Arwa Ismail. (2019). The impact of the prince's work theory on financial rebalancing in administrative contracts. Journal of Studies in the Humanities and Social Sciences, Vol. 2. Volume 23.
  • Omar Alkhouli (2018), Shadow Judiciary, Hidden Courts, Administrative Committees That Practice Judicial and Quasi-Judicial Activities in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Publications of the Saudi Center for Research and Legal Studies, 2nd edition.
  • Sararu, C. S. (2011). The termination of administrative contracts in the Romanian and French law. Acta U. Danubius Jur.‏
  • Shatnawi, Ali Khattar. (2019). The legal qualification of the judges of the Saudi Board of Grievances and its impact on compensation disputes. Journal of Sharia Sciences, Volume 13, Volume 1.
  • Salhab, Kinda Faisal. (2019). A full-fledged lawsuit "Compensation lawsuit": its concept - characteristics - distinguishing it from the annulment lawsuit. Tishreen University Journal of Research and Scientific Studies - Economic and Legal Sciences Series, Vol. 41, v6.
  • Smile, A., & Kak, M. (2020). THE AUTHORITY OF ADMINISTRATION TO WITHDRAW THE WORK FROM THE CONTRACTOR IN PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACT (AN ANALYTICAL STUDY). Journal of college of Law for Legal and Political Sciences, Volume 9.
  • Shantawi, Ali Khattar (2016), The General Theory of Administrative Contracts in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Al-Rushd Library.
  • Sandu, A. M., & Pagarin, M. S. (2012). Study on administrative contracts. Contemp. Readings L. & Soc. Just., 4, 903.‏
  • Wassef Youssef Mohamed. (2019). The legality of the text of the administrative contract on violating the theories of financial rebalancing: a comparative study. Journal of the Islamic University of Sharia and Legal Studies, Vol. 27, Volume. 2.
  • Zabih, Imad Daman, and Arouse, Aisha. (2022). The extent of the permissibility of appealing cancellation in administrative contract disputes. The Thinker Magazine, Vol. 17, Volume 1.
  • Zidan, H. M. (2018). Termination of the administrative contract by dissolution. Journal of The Iraqi University, 40(2).‏
Statistics
Article View: 209
PDF Download: 291