The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية
RIAD, J. (2025). The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية. EKB Journal Management System, 48(48), 1807-1855. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2025.348160.1606
JAMAL RIAD. "The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية". EKB Journal Management System, 48, 48, 2025, 1807-1855. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2025.348160.1606
RIAD, J. (2025). 'The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية', EKB Journal Management System, 48(48), pp. 1807-1855. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2025.348160.1606
RIAD, J. The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية. EKB Journal Management System, 2025; 48(48): 1807-1855. doi: 10.21608/jlr.2025.348160.1606

The Evolution of Constitutional Control of Laws in Morocco and Its Impact on the Referential Question / تطور الرقابة على دستورية القوانين بالمغرب وأثره على المسألة المرجعية

مجلة البحوث الفقهية والقانونية
Article 24, Volume 48, Issue 48, January 2025, Pages 1807-1855    PDF (948.11 K)
Document Type: المقالة الأصلية
DOI: 10.21608/jlr.2025.348160.1606
Author
JAMAL RIAD*
كلية العلوم القانونية والاقتصادية والاجنماعية اكدال - جامعة محمد الخامس - الرباط
Abstract
The aim of control over the constitutionality of laws is to achieve a legal system where legal rules infra-constitutional are compatible, or at least, not inconsistent with the essence of the basic law, and thus the supremacy of the constitution is strengthened. In order for this control to take place, the constitutional judge relies on standards, principles and rules that constitute what is called the Constitutional bloc or referential question.
In Morocco, the extension of constitutional control from a priori to a posteriori, considered as the current trend in comparative constitutional law, can only affirm the kingdom's proactive action in favor of the protection of rights. According to a block of constitutionality that is being built, this extension will allow to control, not only the textual consistency of the norm in a dead letter, but also the practice and the experience that result from it, and which will open the door to extracting democratic interpretations of texts in order to enhance the protection of rights and freedoms.
 
The aim of this paper is to trace the evolutionary path of the control of the constitutionality of laws in Morocco along with clarifying the impact of this development on the issue of expanding the constitutional bloc and strengthening the protection of rights and freedoms. To this end, we have adopted an analytical approach to the texts according to a method that combines the historical approach and the comparative method.
 
تهدف الرقابة على دستورية القوانين إلى الوصول إلى نظام قانوني حيث تتوافق القواعد القانونية دون الدستورية، أو على الأقل، لا تتعارض مع جوهر القانون الأساسي) الدستور(، وبالتالي يتم تعزيز سيادة الدستور. ولكي تتم هذه الرقابة، يستند القاضي الدستوري إلى معايير ومبادئ وقواعد تشكل ما يطلق عليه بالكتلة الدستورية أو المسألة المرجعية.
 إن توسيع الرقابة الدستورية على القوانين في المغرب من الرقابة السابقة إلى اللاحقة عبر دسترة مسطرة الدفع بعدم الدستورية، والتي تُعتبر التوجه الجديد في القانون الدستوري المقارن، لا يمكن إلا أن يؤكد الإرادة الفعلية للمملكة المغربية في ضمان حماية الحقوق، إذ ستمكن هذه الرقابة، وفق الكتلة الدستورية التي تُبنى، من مساءلة النصوص القانونية ليس فقط بناء على الطابع النصي للقاعدة، ولكن أيضًا على الممارسة والتجربة الناتجة عنها وهو ما سيفتح الباب لاستخلاص التأويلات الديمقراطية للنصوص قصد تعزيز حماية الحقوق والحريات.
الهدف من هذه الورقة هو تتبع المسار التطوري للرقابة على دستورية القوانين في المغرب مع توضيح تأثير هذا التطور على مسألة توسيع الكتلة الدستورية وتعزيز حماية الحقوق والحريات. ولأجل ذلك فقد تبنينا مقاربة تحليلية للنصوص وفق منهج يزاوج بين المقاربة التاريخية والمنهج المقارن.
Keywords
Constitution; Constitutional Control; Constitutional Block; A Priori Control; A Posteriori Control; The exception of unconstitutionality; Organic Laws. الدستور؛ الرقابة الدستورية؛ الكتلة الدستورية؛ الرقابة السابقة؛ الرقابة اللاحقة؛ الدفع بعدم الدستورية؛ القوانين التنظيمية
References
  1. Articles
  • BENKHATTAB, "The Moroccan Parliament: Political Regulation and Transitional Uncertainty," REMALD, Current Themes Collection, no. 82, 2013.
  • BERRAMDANE, "Elements of Moroccan Public Law," HARMATTAN, Paris 1994.
  • BERRAMDANE, (1997). Considerations on the Moroccan Constitutional Council. International Yearbook of Constitutional Justice, 12(1996).
  • ELMOR, 'International Conventions and Domestic Law in Jurisprudence,' ed. Documentation, Information, and Training Center in the Field of Human Rights, 2002. (Document in Arabic)."
  • KANTE "The Methods and Techniques of Constitutional Interpretation: The Example of Francophone West African Countries." In Constitutional Interpretation, DALLOZ Editions.2005.
  • KHATAT (1986). Constitutional Justice in Morocco: Contribution to the General Theory of Constitutional Jurisdiction (Doctoral dissertation, Paris 2).
  • SEIGNOBOS, "The Historical Method Applied to the Social Sciences", Paris, Félix Alcan, 1901.
  • FALLON, "The Reference Standards for Judicial Review of Constitutionality," ed. Faculty of Law and Social Sciences of Poitiers. Coll.: Acts & Colloquia. 1st Ed. 2017.
  • S. TĂNĂSESCU, "The Label of Unconstitutionality: A Comparative Legal Test," Romanian Journal of Comparative Law no. 2/2010.
  • BURDEAU, "Manual of Constitutional Law," 22nd ed., LGDJ, Paris 1991.
  • CANIVET and N. MOLFESSIS, "The Jurisprudential Policy," The Creation of Jurisprudential Law: essays in honor of J. BORE, Paris, DALLOZ, 2007..
  • BEATRICE, "The Force of Obédience," Paris, La Découverte, 2006.
  • C. ESCARRAS, "On Two Italian Studies: On the Communicability between the Italian and French Systems of Constitutional Justice," AIJC, II, 1986.
  • CAMBY, "The Organic Law in the 1958 Constitution." Review of Public Law. 1989.
  • DE LA FONTAINE, "The Camel and the Floating Sticks," Fables, first collection: book IV, publisher C. BARBIN & Th. DENYS, Paris, 1678.
  • GICQUEL and P. AVRIL, "Parliamentary Law," MONTCHRESTIEN, 1990.
  • RIAD, "The Exception of Unconstitutionality in Morocco: Nature of Control, Modalities, and Scenarios for Activation", Parliamentary Notebooks (Dafatir Barlamaniya), 3(2), (2024).
  • L HALPÉRIN, "In the Time of Exegesis", in "History of French Private Law Since 1804", Paris 14, PUF, "Quadrige", 2012.
  • -M. BLANQUER, "Block of Constitutionality or Constitutional Order?" in Mélanges JACQUES ROBERT: Liberties, Paris, MONTCHRESTIEN, 1998.
  • -M. BLANQUER, "Block of Constitutionality or Constitutional Order?" in Mélanges JACQUES ROBERT: Liberties, Paris, MONTCHRESTIEN, 1998.
  • FAVOREU, "The Constitutional Courts," Paris, PUF 1992.
  • ACHARGUI, "The Constitutional Council of the Kingdom of Morocco", Dalloz, the New Notebooks of the Constitutional Council" 2011/1 No. 30.
  • ACHERKI, "Organic Laws in Morocco: A Comparative Study," RMDED, no. 1, 1982 (in Arabic).
  • ACHERKI, "Organic Laws in Morocco: A Comparative Study," RMDED, no. 1, 1982 (in Arabic).
  • BENABDALLAH, "The Status of the Moroccan Constitutional Judge in Light of the 2011 Constitution. REMALD. (2012).
  • BENABDALLAH, "What Haj Lfdoul Told me, or Thoughts on the Procedure of the Exception of Unconstitutionality", REMALD, n°141, 2018.
  • A. COHENDET, "Constitutional Law ", LGDJ, 2017.
  • BERNOUSSI, "The Constitutional Control in the Maghreb," thesis for the attainment of a State Doctorate in Law, Mohamed V University, FSJES Rabat, 1998.
  • BERNOUSSI, "The Moroccan Constitution of July 29, 2011: Between Continuity and Ruptures". Public Law Review, (2012). (3).
  • LE BOT, "A Priori and A Posteriori Judicial Control in Europe," Les Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, 2013/3, n° 40
  • BON, "Constitutional Dictionary (O. DUHAMEL and Y. MENYDIR)," PUF edition, Great Dictionaries Collection, 1994, see "a priori control."
  • FERNANDEZ, "The Organic Laws." Madrid 81. Cf. J. CAMBY, "The Organic Law in the 1958 Constitution". Revue de Droit Public. 1989.
  • M. TAMAOUI, "The Three Powers in Arab Constitutions and Islamic Political Thought," Ed DAR ALFIKR AL ARABI. Cairo. 1974, (document in Arabic).
  • GAUDEMET, "The Constitutional Council and the Council of State in the Legislative Process," LGDJ, MONTCHRESTIEN, 1988.
    1. Thesis
  • Merida, "Constitutional Interpretation in the Moroccan Political Regime: The Case of the Constitutional Judge," thesis defended for the doctorate, Faculty of Legal, Economic, and Social Sciences of Fez.2014.
    1. Laws
  • The French Constitution of 1948, Journal officiel de la République française (JORF) le 5 octobre 1958, dans le n° 234.
  • The Moroccan Constitution of 1962, BO no. 2616 of December 19, 1962.
  • The Moroccan Constitution of 1970, BO no. 3013 of August 1, 1970.
  • The Moroccan Constitution of 1972, BO no. 3098 of March 15, 1972.
  • The Moroccan Constitution of 2011, BO no. 5964 of July 30, 2011.
  • The organic law n° 02/2012, BO no. 6066 of July 19, 2012.
  • The Spanish Constitution of 1978, the Official Gazette of the Spanish State (Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE) on December 29, 1978, under BOE No. 311.
    1. jurisprudence
  • Decision of the Constitutional Chamber no. 1 of December 31, 1963. BO no. 2672 of January 10, 1964.
  • Decision of the Constitutional Council no. 921/2013 of August 13, 2013, BO no. 6185.
  • Decision of the French Constitutional Council No. 2018-717/718 QPC of July 6, 2018.
  • Decision of the French Constitutional Council No. 2019-777 QPC of April 19, 2019, JORF No. 0094 of April 20, 2019, text No. 73.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no 382/2000 of March 15, 2000, BO n° 4786 du 13 Avril 2000, p. 661.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no 819/2011 of November 4, 2012
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no 921/2013 of August 13, 2013.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 213/98 of May 28, 1998, BO no. 4598 of June 25, 1998, p. 1844.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 228/98, BO no. 4615 of August 24, 1998, p. 2374.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 829/2012 of February 4, 2012, BO no. 6021 of February 13, 2012.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 838/2012 of February 16, 2012, BO no. 6027 of March 5, 2012, p. 823.
  • Decision of the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 854/2012, BO no. 6054 of June 7, 2012, p. 3550.
  • Decision the Moroccan Constitutional Council no. 924/2013 of August 22, 2013, BO no. 6185, p. 6030.
  • The decision of the First Chamber of the German Federal Constitutional Court on January 27, 2015, the German Federal Law Gazette (Bundesgesetzblatt), 2015.
    1. International conventions
  • The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. United Nations, Treaty Series, vol. 1155, p. 331.

Webography

 

Statistics
Article View: 315
PDF Download: 201