الوساطة كأحد الوسائل البديلة لتسوية المنازعات الإدارية / Mediation as a Means of Settling Administrative Disputes

• قواعد الأونسيترال للوساطة (2021)

https://uncitral.un.org/ar/texts/mediation/modellaw/commercial_conciliation

• Alternative Dispute Resolution: The Latest Pledge Report 2008-09. Ministry of Justice. 2009. Available at:

https://www.justice.gov.uk/publications/alternative-dispute-resolution-2008-09.htm

• As-Politics: Journal of Constitutional Law, E-ISSN 2798-3528, Vol. 4 No. 1 (2024). DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24042/as-siyasi.v4i1.21667
• As-Siyasi. (2024). Various articles. As-Siyasi: Journal of Constitutional Law, 4(1)
• Association of the Councils of State and Supreme Administrative Jurisdictions of the European Union i.n.p.a. (2013, May 15). The Act of 14 June 1960 - Code of Administrative Proceedings (consolidated text Journal of Laws 2013, item 267). Available at: www.juradmin.eu/index.php/en/tour-d-europe-en
• Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine. Available at:

https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2747-15

• Constitutional Court of Ukraine. (2002). Decision in the case on the constitutional petition of the Limited Liability Company "Trading House Campus Cotton Club" regarding the official interpretation of part two of Article 124 of the Constitution of Ukraine (Case No. v015p710-02)
• Constitution of Ukraine. Available at:

https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254к/96-вр#Text

• Department for Constitutional Affairs. (1999). Inaugural Lecture to the Faculty of Mediation and ADR. Available at:

https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.dca.gov.uk/speeches/1999/271-99.htm

• Dauter, B., Postępowanie mediacyjne i uproszczone, 329; W. Chróścielewski, Z. Kmieciak, J.P. Tarno, Reforma sądownictwa administracyjnego a standardy ochrony prawa jednostki, „Państwo i Prawo" 2002, Book .
• Judiciary of the United Kingdom. (2008, May 8). Speech by Clarke LJ. Available at: http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/media/speeches/2008/speech-clarke-lj-mor08052008
• Law Institute of Victoria, ADR Terminology: Responses to NADRAC Discussion Paper (National Alternative Dispute Resolution Advisory Council, 24 June 2005)
• Law of Ukraine. (n.d.). On Amendments to the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine, the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine, the Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine and Other Legislative Acts. Available at:

https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2147-19#Text

• Law of Ukraine. (n.d.). On Mediation. Available at:

https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1875-20#Text

• Law of Ukraine, accessed March 10, 2023. Available at:

https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1402-19

• Law of Ukraine "On Administrative Procedure", accessed October 13, 2023. Available at: https://zakonrada.gov.ua/laws/show/2073-20#Text
• Law reform commission - report alternative dispute resolution: mediation and conciliation-law reform commission First published November 2010.
• Law Reform Commission, Report on the Third Programme of Law Reform 2008–2014, LRC 86–2007.
• National Association of Mediators of Ukraine. Mediation in the World. 2016. Available at: http://namu.com.ua/ua/info/mediation/in-the-world/
• Resolution in India. Available at:

http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/docs/speeches/lcj_adr_india_290308.pdf

• State Courts of Singapore. Code of Ethics and Basic Principles on Court Mediation. Available at: https://www.cjc.ccm.gc.ca/cmslib/general/news_pub judicial conduct Principles en pdf
• Supreme Administrative Court. Informacja o działalności sądów administracyjnych w roku 2004, Warszawa 2005, 17
• Supreme Court of Indonesia. (2016). Supreme Court Regulation No. 1 of 2016 on Mediation Procedures in Court (Articles 1(14), 2(1), and 2(2)
• http://www.justice.gov.uk/publications/docs/Twisting-arms-mediation-report-Genn-et-al.pdf
• United Nations, UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Mediation and International Settlement Agreements Resulting from Mediation, 2018. Available at: https://www.un.org/en

ثانيا: المراجع الأجنبية:

• Administrative Disputes: An Appraisal of the Historical and Legal," Journal of International Legal Communication 1, no. 1 (June 2021): 197-204.
• Agnieszka Romanko: Mediation organs in proceedings before administrative courts - Portfolio of the Legal Committee of the Polish Academy of Sciences, 2015
• Alexander J. Brittin: Alternative Dispute Resolution in Government.
• American Arbitration Association and American Bar Association, Code of Ethics for Commercial Arbitrators (Canon III, revised 2004). Available at: http://www.finra.org/web/groups/arbitrationmediation/@arbmed/@arbtors/documents/arbmed/p123778.pdf
• Anna Budnik': MEDIATION BEFORE ADMINISTRATIVE COURTS IN POLAND - Chapter 4.
• Anna Kalisz: When a State Is a Party to a Dispute - (Court-) Administrative Mediation in Poland and in Ukraine (A Comparative Perspective), Review of European and Comparative Law | 2023, Vol. 53, No. 2, pp. 129-148. Published: 30 June 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31743/recl.15967
• Anna Kalisz and Adam Zienkiewicz, Mediacja sądowa i pozasądowa. Zarys wykładu (Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2014).
• Anna Kalisz, ‘Mediacja administracyjna i sądowoadministracyjna’ 2 Państwo i Prawo 19–39. (2018)
• Nilgun Serdar Simsek and Attorney Kerim Bolten: Mediation as a Charming Dispute Resolution Mechanism. Available at:

https://www.gsghukuk.com/en/publications-bulletins/articles/mediation-as-a-charming-dispute-resolution-mechanism-gsg.pdf

• Zivilrechts-Mediations-Gesetz [Civil Law Mediation Act], BGBII 2003/29. Published June 6, 2003.
• Annual Reports, The Supreme Administrative Court, accessed March 10, 2023. Available at: http://www.nsa.gov.pl/sprawozdania-roczne.php
• Baylis, Erin. “Reviewing Statutory Models of Mediation/Conciliation in New Zealand: Three Conclusions” (1999) Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, vol. 30. Available at:

http://www.austlii.edu.au/nz/journals/VUWLawRw/1999/38.html

• Bernard Mayer, "Facilitative mediation," in Divorce and Family Mediation: Models, Methods, and Applications, eds. Jay Folberg, Ann L. Milne, and Peter Salem (London: Routledge, 2004): 29-52.
• Bondy V. Mulcahy L. (2009) Mediation and judicial review: empirical research study. The Public Law Project. www.publiclawproject.org.uk
• Broniewicz W., Marciniak A., Kunicki I., Postępowanie cywilne w zarysie [Outline of Civil Procedure], Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2016.
• Budi Aspani, "Eksistensi Peradilan Tata Usaha Negara dalam Penyelenggaraan Pemerintahan," Jurnal Universitas Palembang 17, no. 2 (May 2019): 114.
• Carries Menkel-Meadow, Toward Another View of Legal Negotiation: The Structure of Problem Solving, 31 UCLA L. Rev. 754, 793 (1984) (analyzing the importance of information exchange for resolving disputes).
• CEPEJ Guidelines Against the Background of the Council of Europe Recommendations.
• Chaban, N., Elgström, O., Knodt, M. Perceptions of EU mediation and mediation effectiveness: Comparing perspectives from Ukraine and the EU. Cooperation and Conflict, 54(4) (2019), p. 506-523.
• Chan, Edwin H.W & Suen, Henry C.H.: Legal issues of dispute management in international Construction Projects Contracting – Construction Law Journal 2005.
• Christopher D. Montez: Illinois's Public Works Contract Change Order Act and Similar Statutes from Other Jurisdictions – Construction Lawyer Journal, 2005.
• Clih (R.), A Comparison between Arbitration and Mediation (The English Perspective), London, Global Legal Group LTD, 2006, p. 20.
• Criteria for the Appropriate Use of Mediation in Construction Disputes: Judicial Statements in the English Technology and Construction Court (2009) [International Journal of Law in the Built Environment].
• Consultation Paper on Alternative Dispute Resolution (LRC CP 50-2008), referred to as the Consultation Paper in the remainder of this Report.
• Costa Rica Law on Alternative Dispute Resolution of Disputes and Promotion of Freedom from Social Unrest art 16 (2000) (disqualifying mediator from participating as an arbitrator in subsequent proceedings).
• Croatia Law on Conciliation art. 13 (2003), in Int'l Handbook on Cmm. Arb. Supp. 57, Croatia, Annex II, available at 227.
• Cyril Chern: The Law of Construction Disputes (3rd edn, 2010).
• Conditions of Contract for Construction for Building and Engineering Work - Designed by the Employer - Second Edition 2017.
• https://www.gov.pl/web/sprawiedliwosc/dane-statystyczne-dotyczace-mediacji
• Daniel Kahneman & Shane Frederick, Representativeness Revisited: Attribute Substitution in Intuitive Judgment, in Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment 49, 49 (Thomas Gilovich, Dale Griffin & Daniel Kahneman eds., 2002), p. 228.
• David Richbell: Mediation of Construction Disputes, Wiley-Blackwell, 1st Edition, 2008.
• Deason, Ellen E., ‘Limiting Judicial Discretion: Distinguishing “Managing” from “Settling” Under Rule 16’ (unpublished manuscript).
• Deason, Ellen E., ‘Predictable Mediation Confidentiality in the US Federal System’ (2002) 17 Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution 239, 259–69.
• Dean O'Leary: Using Dispute Adjudication Boards to Resolve Construction Disputes, February 2016, p. 89.
• Delphine Wietek, France in Nadja Alexander, Sabine Walsh and Martin Svatos eds, EU Mediation Law Handbook: Regulatory Robustness Ratings for Mediation § 12.09 (2017).
• De Palo G. Trevor MB: EU Mediation. Law and Practice, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 656 pp (2012).
• Dejan Vučetić: Is Mediation Viable in Administrative Matters?, Facta Universitatis - Series: Law and Politics, Vol. 14, No. 4, 2016.
• Dimitrijević, Upravno pravo opšti deo (2nd revised and updated edition) Administrative Law-General Part. Niš: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Nišu, 2014.
• Dragos, D. C., Neamtu, B. (Eds.). Alternative Dispute Resolution in European Administrative Law. Springer, 2014.
• Directive 2008/52/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2008 on certain aspects of mediation in civil and commercial matters, OJ L136, 24.5.2008, pp. 3–8, recital 11.
• Directive 2008/52/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2008 on certain aspects of mediation in civil and commercial matters [2008] OJ L136/3, recital 13.
• Drozdov, O., Rozhnov, O., & Mamnitskyi, V., Mediation and Court in Ukraine: Perspectives on Interaction and Mutual Understanding, Access to Justice in Eastern Europe, 2021, 4(3), p. 181.
• Duvinić, M., Evropski ombudsman i loša uprava (European Ombudsman and Maladministration), Beograd: Zaštitnik gradana, 2013.
• Dwi Sriyantini, Principles of Non-litigation Mediation as an Alternative for Civil Dispute Resolution in Indonesia (Thesis, University of Jember 2011).
• Duncan Wallace, The ICE Conditions of Contract (Fifth Edition), A Commentary, London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1978.Ellen E Deason, ‘Combinations of Mediation and Arbitration with the Same Neutral: A Framework for Judicial Review’ (2013) 5 Yearbook on Arbitration and Mediation art 12.
• Ethical Guidelines developed by the Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of the State Bar of Texas and the Supreme Court of Texas state that “[a] person serving as a mediator generally should not subsequently serve as a judge, master, guardian ad litem, or in any other judicial or quasi-judicial capacity in matters that are the subject of the mediation.” Tex Sup Ct, Approval of Ethical Guidelines for Mediators, Misc Docket No 05-9107 (13 June 2005)

http://www.supreme.courts.state.tx.us/MiscDocket/05/05910700.pdf See also Supreme Court Approves Ethical Guidelines for Mediators, 68 Tex B J 856, 857–58 (2005).

• European Commission, European Code of Conduct for Mediators (2004) http://ec.europa.eu/civiljustice/adr/adr_ec_code_conduct_en.pdf
• European Commission, European Code of Conduct for Mediators, European e-Justice Portal http://ec.europa.eu/civil-justice/adr/adr_ec_en.htm accessed 10 March 2025.
• European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ), Promoting the Use of Mediation in Administrative Matters CEPEJ(2022)11 (7 December 2022) https://rm.coe.int/cepej-2022-11-promoting-administrative-mediation-en-adopted/1680a95692 accessed 16 June 2023.
• European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice. (2008, May 24). Guidelines for a better implementation of the existing recommendation concerning family mediation and civil mediation. Official Journal of the European Union, OJ L 136.
• European Parliament and Council. (2008). Directive 2008/52/EC on certain aspects of mediation in civil and commercial matters. Official Journal of the European Union, L 136, 3–8.
• https://eurlex.europa.eu/legalcontent/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32008L0052
• Ewa Gmurzyńska and Rafał Morek (eds), Mediacja. Teoria i praktyka (Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2014).
• Foucher, Olivier, La médiation: outil de pacification des relations sociales, Dalloz, Paris, 2015Federczyk, Mediation in administrative and court-administrative proceedings
• Frederick R. Fucci, «Hardship and Changed Circumstances as Excuse for non – Performance of contracts – Practical Considerations in international Infrastructure Investment and Finance» p. 32, TDM, Volume 4 issueno. 5, septmber 2007
• Fricero n., butruille-cardew c., benrais l., gorchs- gelzer b. Et payan g., le guide des modes amiables de résolution des différends - 2014/2015, 101 dalloz, 2014.
• FIDIC Red Book 2017, Clause 21, Dispute Avoidance and Adjudication Board (DAAB(
• FIDIC Conditions of Contract for EPC/TURNKEY PROJECTS- Second Edition 2017.
• (2017). Conditions of Contract for Construction for Plant and Design-Build for Electrical and Mechanical Plant, and for Building and Engineering Works, Designed by the Contractor (2nd ed.). Fédération Internationale des Ingénieurs-Conseils (FIDIC(.
• Fiona (B), A Practical guide to Lawyering skills, Routledge, 2nd Edition, 2003
• Galanter M (1974) Why the "Haves" come out abead: peculations on the limits of legal change - Law Soc Rev 9:95-160
• Gmurzyńska, E., & Morek, R. (Eds.). (2018). Mediacje. Teoria i praktyka [Mediation. Theory and Practice]. Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer.
• Golann D (2009) Mediating legal disputes: effective strategies for neutrals and advocates. Amer- ican Bar Association, Chicago, 370 pp
• Guidelines for Lawmaking in the Field of Mediation European Handbook for Mediation Lawmaking, European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ), accessed March 10, 2023, https://rm.coe.int/cepej-2019-9-en-handbook/1680951928.
• Halsbury's Laws of England – Building Contracts (Volume 6) – 5th Edition2011
• Henry J. Brown and Arthur L. Mariot, Adr Principles And Practice 127 2Nd Ed. Sweet & Maxwell, 1997.
• H Genn et al. Twisting Arms: Court-referred and court-linked mediation under judicial pressure (May 2007) Ministry of Justice Research Series 1/07 at

http://www.justice.gov.uk/publications/docs/Twisting-arms-mediation- report-Genn-et-al.pdf

• Hopt KJ, Steffek F (eds) (2013) Mediation principles and regulation in comparative perspective. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1408 pp
• Humphreys D, "Alternative Dispute Resolution Processes in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in the Light of Recent Amendments to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975" (Paper presented at the Institute of Arbitrators and Mediators of Australia Conference, Canberra, 27-29 May 2005).
• Indriati Amarini, "Effective and Efficient Dispute Resolution Through Optimization of Mediation in Court," Journal Kosmik Hukum 16, no. 2 (June 2016): 93, Dian Maris Rahmah, "Optimization of Dispute Resolution Through Mediation in Court," Journal Bina Mulia Hukum 4, no. 1 (September 2019):
• The Institute of Company Secretaries of India and Mediation and Conciliation Project Committee (Supreme Court of India), Mediation Training Manual of India: Arbitration, Mediation & Conciliation – Group 2 (ICSI, New Delhi) 42, 354.
• International Bar Association, Rules of Ethics for International Arbitrators (1964) r 5.3.
• Jameel Tar Mohamed: Dispute Review Boards in UK construction Alternative dispute resolution - Construction Law (Journal)/ 2010/ Issue 6, 2010
• James J. Alfini, Risk of Coercion Too Great, DISP. RESOL, MAG., Fall 1999, at 11, 14; James J. Alfini, 2-Trashing, Bashing, and Hashing It Out: Is This the End of "Good Mediation"?. 19 FLA. ST. U. L. Rev. 47 (1991(
• Janičijević, D. Sudsko poravnanje i medijacija [Judicial Settlement and Mediation). Tematski zbornik radova "Dvadeset godina Zakona o vanpraničnom postupku Republike Srbije", Niš. (2003).
• Jans JH et al (eds) Europeanisation of public law. Europa Law Publishing. Groningen . (2007(
• Jean-Bernard Auby, Droit de la médiation administrative, LGDJ, Paris, 2016.
• Jean-François Roberge & Dorcas Quek Anderson:JUDICIAL MEDIATION: FROM DEBATES TO RENEWAL- SOURCE: Content Downloaded from HeinOnline, DOWNLOADED: Sat Jun 6 04:04:14 2020.
• Jędrejek G. (ed.), Postępowanie cywilne po nowelizacji. Vademecum [Civil Procedure after the Amendment Act. Vademecum), Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2020. Kmiecik Z.R., Postępowania administracyjne, postępowanie egzekucyjne w administracji
• John Murdch, will Hughes, construction contracts law and management, fourth Edition.
• Judith Resnik, Mediating Preferences. Litigant Preferences for Process and Judicial Preferences for Settlement, 2002 J. DISP. RESOL. 155, 168.
• Karmaza, O,Institute of mediation: basic concepts of development. Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, . (2017p.-28.
• Karyna Valeriivna Rostovska , Nataliia Viktorivna Hryshyna , Olesia Yuryevna Kaidash and Marharyta Sergeevna Syromiatnikova Mediation as a tool for resolving administrative conflicts. An assessment of historical and legal aspectsPublished: January 12th, 2021.
• Kateryna Honcharenko and others: CIArb Professional Practice Guideline on the Use of Mediation in Arbitration Professional Practice Guideline on the Use of Mediation in Arbitration (2021)-Practice and Standards Committee 2021.
• Khoiruddin Manahan Siregar, "Kedudukan Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara di Indonesia," Jurnal Al-Maqasid: Jurial Umu-Ilmu Kesyariahan dan Keperdataan 6, no. 1 (2020(
• Klaus Peter Berger, Integration of Mediation Elements into Arbitration; 'Hybrid Procedures and 'Intuitive Mediation by International Arbitrators, 19 ARB. INT'L 387, 391 (2003); Michael Collins, Do International Arbitral Tribunals Have any Obligations to Encourage Settlement of the Disputes Before Them?, 19 ARB. INT'L 333, 334 (200(
• Klonowski, in: H. Knysiak-Sudyka (ed.), Code of Administrative Procedure. Commentary, Warsaw: LEX/el., 2023, Article 13.
• Kordasiewicz S., Historyczna i międzynarodowa perspektywa mediacji [Historical and international perspectives on mediation], [in:] E. Gmurzyńska, R. Morek (eds.), Me- -diacje. Teoria i praktyka [Mediation. Theory and Practice), Wolters Kluwer, War- saw 2018.
• Implementation of Mediation in the Administrative Process of Ukraine. Doctoral thesis. Uzhhorod National University, Uzhhorod, Ukraine, (2019). Available at https://www.uzhnu.edu.ua/uk/infocentre/get/19680
• Kovač, Mediation and Settlement in Administrative Matters in Slovenia. Hrvatska javna uprava (2010(
• Krzysztof Pleszka et al, Mediacja. Teoria, normy, praktyka (Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2017(.
• Lauren Robel, Fractured Procedure: The Civil Justice Reform Act of 1990, 46 STAN. L. REV. 1447, 1447 1994
• Lord Chancellor's Department. Press release: In future, government departments will only go to court as a last resort... Instead, government legal disputes will be settled by mediation or arbitration whenever possible. (2001, March 23).
• Lord Judge, ‘Speech at the Third Civil Mediation Council National Conference’ (London, 14 May 2009) http://www.civilmediation.org
• Lucille M. Ponte, Thomas D. Cavenagh, Alternative Dispute Resolution in Business, West Educational Publishing Company, 1991.
• Magdalena Tabernacka, Negocjacje i mediacje w sferze publicznej (Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2018).Wojciech Federczyk, Mediacja w postępowaniu administracyjnym i sądowoadministracyjnym (Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2013(
• Marseille, A.T.; Tolsma, H.D:Mediation in Administrative Proceedings de Graaf, K.J- University of Groningen, Alternative Dispute Resolution in European Administrative Law. Publication date: 2014 .
• Marseille AT, De Graaf KJ. (2012) Criteria to assess the quality of the Dutch informal pro-active approach model In: Dragos DC, Lafarge F, Willemsen P (eds) Proceedings of the 33rd annual EGPA-conference of the permanent study group: law and public administration. Editura Economica, Bucharest.
• Marseille, & J. de Ridder (Eds.), Quality of decision-making in public law: Studies in administrative decision-making in the Netherlands (pp. Groningen: Europa Law Publishing.
• Martyna Plucińska-Nowak, Status i oblicza mediacji w społeczeństwie polskim (Wydawnictwo UAM, Poznań 2021(.
• Massachusetts General Court. (2005). Chapter 36 of the Acts of 2005.
• (2007). MCFM family mediation quarterly, 6(1), 1. Retrieved from http://www.mcfm.org/pdf/spring07.pdf
• Mediation in PERMA No. 1 of 2016 is defined as a method of dispute resolution through a negotiation process to obtain an agreement between the parties with the assistance of a mediator, See Septi Wulan Sari, "Mediasi Dalam Peraturan Mahkamah Agung Nomor 1 Tahun 2016," Ahkam 5, no. 1 (July 2017): 8.
• Mediation in Judicial Review: A practical handbook for lawyers Published by The Public Law Project 150 Caledonian Road London NI 9RD The Public Law Project 2011 .
• Milkov, D. Upravno pravo L. Uvodna i organizaciona pitanja [Administrative Law 1, Introductory and Organizational Issues). Novi Sad: Univerzitet u Novom Sadu-Pravni fakultet-Centar za izdavačku delatnost(2012(.
• Mohammad Hossein Hajaryan, Iraj Golduzian & Ehsan Hajarian. Mediation from thePenological Viewpoint. JOURNAL CITA HUKUM (INDONESIAN LAW JOURNAL) 2. 2019. Pp. 157-168, 160. Available at: https://doi.org/10.15408/jch.v712.10718
• Mojašević, A. Ekonomska analiza medijacije (teorijsko-empirijska stalija) [Economic Analysis of Mediation: a theoretical-empirical study). Niš. Pravni fakultet. (2014(
• Mirosław Karpiuk: Mediation in administrative proceedings and its role in the amicable resolution of disputes- ADR. Arbitration and Mediation -vol. 16, 1, 20, Poland.p.23
• Moll T., Mediacja w postępowaniu administracyjnym [Mediation in Administrative Proceedings], [in:] J. Jaskiernia, K. Spryszak (eds.), Nowe wyzwania i rozwiązania w polskim systemie ochrony praw człowieka [New Challenges and Solutions in the Polish Human Rights Protection System], Wyd. Adam Marszałek, Toruń 2018.
• Moll T., Postępowanie mediacyjne na gruncie ustawy Prawo o postępowaniu przed sądami administracyjnymi [Mediation Proceedings under the Law on Proceedings before Administrative Courts). Kwartalnik ADR 2015, No. 2(30).
• Mazaraki, N. (2016) Mediation in Ukraine: Problems of theory and practice. *Foreign Trade, Economics, Finance, Law, 84(1), 92–100. Retrieved June 16, 2023, from [http://journals.knute.edu.ua/foreigntrade/article/view/533](http://journals.knute.edu.ua/foreign-trade/article/view/533
• Mutuel L. Mofis, Under Kupfer Scheder. Dopute Resolution Examples and Explanat Wolters Klower Law A Buzias Second Edition, 2011,
• [Report no. 23, p. 9]. See also: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW),
• National Alternative Dispute Resolution Advisory Council ("NADRAC"), Dispute Resolution Terms, (2003)
• Nelikoglu, B. Speech by Mr. Burakhan Nelikoglu, Judge on the Council of State of Turkey, Rapporteur for the Public Service Commission. Report by the Public Service Commission.
• Nockleby, J.T. (2008–2009). Access to justice: It’s not for everyone. Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review, 42
• L. Bondarenko-Zelinska, Introduction of Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods: European Experience for Ukraine, Private Law and Entrepreneurship, Vol. 8, 200.
• Nosworthy, Lan. The Future of Arbitration and Mediation, The Arbitrator & Mediator, April 2003.End Date: 31 December 2021
• Oana Ruxandra Gherghina, Comparative Study between FIDIC Dispute Adjudication and Negotiation as Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods, 2017 Conf. Int'l Dr. 252 (2017(
• OECD, Alternative Dispute Resolution in Administrative Law, Policy Studies, 2020.
• Oleg Yaroshenko, Maryna O. Pyzhova, Yuliia Yu. Ivchuk, Natalya M. Vapnyarchuk, Maryna O. Savielieva: The use of mediation in administrative proceedings: the experience of European Union member states- https://revista.unicuritiba.edu.br/index.php/RIMA/article/view/5510/0 Inicio > Vol. 3, Núm. 32 (2021(
• Oleksandra Karmaza. Institute of Mediation: Basic Concepts of Development. ENTREPRENEURSHIP, ECONOMY AND LAW 2, 2017. Pp. 24.
• Paul A. Géias, Dispute prevention and settlement through Expert determination and dispute Boards, Dossiers of the ICC Institute of world Biasness law, volume 15 (Kluwer Law International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) 2017, p. 7.
• Paul Newman, Do variation, have to be valued fairly – construction Law journal – October 2000, ..
• Paweł Rochowicz, "Klapa mediacji, ale uproszczenia działają - resort rozwoju ocenia wpro- wadzone procedury," Prawo.pl, accessed March 10, 2023, https://www.prawo.pl/samorzad/uproszczenia-procedur-administracyjnych-niezawsze-dzialaja, 516368.html
• Philip J. Harter, Dispute Resolution and Administrative Law: The History, Needs, and Future of a Complex Relationship, 29 Vill. L. Rev. 1393 (1983) K. Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.villanova.edu/vlr/vol29/iss6/6
• Peter Mills: How to avoid the specter of arbitration - Business Day (South Africa) Law Review Edition- August 14, 2006 - SECTION: ECONOMY, BUSINESS & FINANCE; .
• Petrušić, N. Medijacija kao metod rešavanja sporova (Mediation as a method for Resolving of Disputes). Temida 7(2). Beograd. Viktimološko društvo Srbije(2004)
• Pitschas R Mediation as a method and instrument for conflict resolution in the public sector. New Journal of Administrative Law 23:396-402(2004(
• Podkovenko, Mediation as an Alternative Way of Resolving Conflicts: Genesis and Institutional Framework, Current Issues of Jurisprudence, Vol. 9, 2017.
• Poncelet, Bruno, La Médiation dans les litiges administratifs, Revue française de droit administratif, 2019.
• Przybysz, Code of Administrative Procedure. Commentary, Warsaw: LEX/el., 2021.
• Potemkina, Y. (2019). Mediation in family disputes. Yurydychna Gazeta. Retrieved from

http://yur-gazeta.com/publications/practice/simeyne-pravo/mediaciya-u-simeyni-hsporah-shlyah-do-primirennya-porozuminnya-tavregulyuvannya.htm

• Postępowanie sądowoadministracyjne [Administrative Proceedings, Enforcement Proceedings and Administrative Court Proceedings), Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2019. Konieczna K., Zasada słuszności jako przesłanka odpowiedzialności władzy publicznej [Liability of Public Authorities Based on the Principle of Equity), „Studia Prawn- oustrojowe" 2019, No. 44.
• Przylepa-Lewak, Mediation as a form of communication in administrative proceedings, Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Skłodowska. Sectio G (Ius)" 2022,
• REPORT ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION: MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION (LRC 98-2010) COPYRIGHT Law Reform Commission FIRST PUBLISHED November 2010 ISSN 1393-3132

https://www.lawreform.ie/_fileupload/reports/r98adr.pdf

• Robert j. Gomez: mediating government contract claims: how it is different- public contract law journal vol. 32, no. 1 fall 2002.
• Rostovska, K. & Hryshyna, N. Mediations in administrative proceeding: myth or reality nowadays. The Journalof V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Series: "Law", 29(2020), p. 182-188.
• Ryan, M. (2008). Access to justice and unmet legal needs. Illinois Law and Technology, 26, 325–342.
• Savings & Investment Bank Ltd (in liquidation) v Fincken [2009] EWHC 1102 (TCC), [2009] BLR 399 (TCC)
• Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration,ARBITRATION RULES,MEDIATION RULES,July 2016-Shawwal 143,Copyright © 2016 Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration.
• Sorysz M., Kontrola czynności dyspozytywnych w sprawach z zakresu prawa pracy i ubezpieczeń społecznych [Supervision of Dispositive Activities in Matters of Labour Law and Social Security). „Studia z Zakresu Prawa Pracy i Polityki Społec znej 2017, Vol. 24, No. 4.
• SILARD (S.A), Clauses de maintien de la valeur dans Les transactions internationals, JDI, 1972 .
• Szpor A., Mediacja w prawie administracyjnym (Mediation in Administrative Law).
• Sophie Boyron, Mediation in Administrative Law: The Identification of Conflicting Paradigms, 13 EUR. PUB. L. 263, 268 2007.
• Stephen B. Goldberg, Frank E.A. Sander And Nancy H. Rogers, Dispute Resolution Negotiation, Mediation And Other Processes 123 3rd Ed. Aspine Law & Business, 1999.
• Tański, M. (n.d.). Mediacja facylitatywna [Facilitative Mediation]. Retrieved from

http://www.mediacje.lex.pl/czytaj/-/artykul/mediacja-facylitatywna

• Telenga P., Komentarz aktualizowany do art. 183(1) Kodeksu postępowania cywilnego [Revised comments to Article 183(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure], [in:] P. Telenga (ed.), Kodeks postępowania cywilnego. Komentarz aktualizowany [The Code of Civil Procedure. Commentary updated], 2019, Lex.
• Tolsma, H. D. (2007). How can mediation be implemented in the current administrative decision-making process? In K. J. De Graaf, J. H. Jans, A. T.
• Tomasz Moll: Mediation in administrative law - Polish regulations in the light of the European recommendations- Uniwersytet Jana Kochanowskiego w Kielcach-2024 P 276
• Tomić, Z. (2002). Upravno pravo sistem (četvrto, doterano izdanje) [Administrative Law System (4th updated edition)]. Beograd: Službeni list SRJ.
• Tsuvina, T. (2017). Introduction of the institute of court mediation as a promising area for reforming the civil procedure legislation of Ukraine. In I. O. Izarova & R. Y. Khanyk-Pospolitak (Eds.), Ukraine on the way to Europe: Reform of civil procedural legislation. 36 scientific works. Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference (Kyiv, 7 July 2017) (pp. 195–200). Kyiv: Dakor Publishing House.Available at:

https://dspace.nlu.edu.ua/bitstream/123456789/12731/1/Cuvina_195-200.pdf

• Tsuvina, T. (2022). National mechanisms of the enforcement of agreements resulting from mediation: EU experience and Ukrainian perspectives.Problems of Legality, (158), 110–123.

[https://doi.org/10.21564/2414990X.158.264998](https://doi.org/10.21564/2414-990X.158.264998 (

• Uniform Mediation Act, drafted by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws and approved and recommended for enactment in all states, August 10–17, 2001, and amended August 1–7, 2003. Available at:

http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/archives/ulc/mediat/2003finaldraft.htm

• Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine-Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine. Retrieved from-. (2005). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2747-15#Text
• Verda Bondy. Margaret Doyle, Mediation in Judicial Review: A Practical Handbook for Lawyers. The Public Law Project, London, Britain, July, 2011. P.1
• Vučetić, D. (2014). Evropska upravno-procesna pravila: Opšti upravni postupak Republike Srbije [European administrative procedural rules and general administrative procedure of Republic of Serbia]. Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Nišu, (68), 175–186.
• Wang, W. (2005). The role of conciliation in resolving disputes: A P.R.C. perspective. Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution, 20, 421–422.
• Weldon Plant Ltd V. Commission for New Towns [2000] EWHC Technology.
• Wierzbowski M., Postępowania administracyjne ogólne, podatkowe, egzekucyjne i przed sądami administracyjnymi [Administrative proceedings General. Tax, And Enforcement Proceedings, and Proceedings Before Administrative Courts]. C.H. Beck, Warsaw 2017.
• Wróbel A., Jaśkowska M., Wilbrandt-Gotowicz M., Kodeks postepowania administra cyjnego. Komentarz [The Code of Administrative Procedure. A Commentary], Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw 2020.
• Kmieciak, Mediation in Polish administrative law, [in:] H. Machińska (ed.). Mediation in administrative cases, Warsaw 2007.
• Zimmermann J., Prawo administracyjne [The administrative law),
• Zubco, A. Opportunities and perspectives on the application of Mediation in the activity of public administration. Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference" Social Changes in the Global World",(2019). 1(6)

References:

almualafat alama:

• (surat albaqara alaya) 143.
• muhamad kamil eubayd, astiqlal alqada' ", matbueat nadaa alqudat almisria alqahirata, mars, 1991.
• muhamad eabd alghani hilali, alqada' al'iidariu watatawur fikrat almashrueiat fi masara, dar alnahdat alearabiati, 2018.
• maqayis allughat liabn faris (6/108).
• yhyaa aljumla, alqanun al'iidari: qada' wataeliq watahlili, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahiratu, ta. 2005.

almualafat almutakhasisa:

• 'ahmad eabd alkarim salamat, alnazariat aleamat lilnuzum alwudiyat litaswiat almunazaeati, almufawadati, alwisatat , altawfiqi, alsalha, bdylaan ean almuetarak alqadayiy, dar alnahdat alearabiati: alqahirat altabeat al'uwlaa 2013.
• 'ahmad muhamad alsaawaa, taswiat almunazaeat alnaashiat ean aleuqud alduwliat lilbina' waltashyid (dirasat muqaranati) - dar alnahdat alearabiat altabeat al'uwlaa 2012.
• rubirt karb runald stidham :al'iijra'at alqadayiyat fi 'amrika ", tarjamat di. eala' 'abu zid, aljameiat almisriat linashr almaerifat walthaqafat alealamiati, altabeat althaaniatu, almujalad althaani, alqahiratu, nufimbir, 1977.
• saeid albazi, halu almunazaeat fi aleuqud alduwliati: alwisatat waltahkimu, altabeat althaaniatu, dar alnahdat alearabiati, 2020.
• fawaadeabd alfataah muradi, alwasayil albadilat litaswiat almunazaeat fi aleuqud alduwliati, dar alfikr aljamieii, 2021.
• ealiu aljasimi, alwasayil albadilat lihali almunazaeati.alwisatat waltahkimi, dar alnashr alqanuniati, 2018.
• esam 'ahmad albuhjaa, altahkim faa euqud (B.O.T), aliaskandariatu, dar aljamieat aljadidat lilnashri, 2008.
• fahad alsaalimu, alwisatat fi almunazaeat al'iidariati: dirasat muqaranati, dar althaqafat alqanuniati, 2020.
• muhamad 'abu aleala, alwisatat waltahkim kawasayil badilat litaswiat almunazaeati, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahirati, 2017.
• muhamad muhamad badran, eaqad al'iinsha'at faa alqanun almusraa (dirasat faa almushkilat aleamaliat lieuqud aliatihad alduwlaa lilmuhandisin al'iistishariiyna) - dar alnahdat alearabiat - alqahirat 2001.
• mahmud eabd alhamid, dawr alwisatat fi 'iislah aleadalat al'iidariat fi masar, almutamar alsanawii likuliyat alhuquq - jamieat alqahirati, 2021.

al'utruhat alamalia:

• earawi eabd alkarim: alturuq albadilat fi hali alnizaeat alqadayiya "alsulh w alwisatat alqadayiyatu" tibqan liqanun al'iijra'at almadaniat wal'iidariat mudhakiratan muqadimatan linayl shahadat almajistir eam 2012 .
• eilawat badran, alwisatat badil lihali alnizae watatbiqatiha fi alfiqh al'iislamii w qanun al'iijra'at almadaniat w al'iidariat aljazayirii - risalat muqadimat linayl darajat aldukturah fi takhasus alsharieat walqanun likuliyat aleulum al'iinsaniat walaijtimaeiat waleulum alsiyasiat jamieat alhaji likhadari-aljazayir 2014.
• fatih khilafi, makanat alwisatat altaswiat alnizae al'iidariu fi alqanun aljazayirii : risalat muqadimat linayl darajat aldukturah fi alqanun likuliyat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiat jamieat muhamad khaydar bisikrati-aljazayir 2014
• mahir muhamad 'ahmad hamid, alnizam alqanunaa lieaqd albut (BOT), risalat dukturah muqadimatan likuliyat alhuquq jamieat alzaqaziq, 2007
• muhamad fuad muhamad alhariri :sultat al'iidarat fi taedil euqud al'ashghal aleamat wifqan linizam 'awamir altaghyir : dirasat muqaranat bayn alqanun almisrii w euqud al'iinsha'at alnamudhajiat -'utaruhat muqadimat linayl darajat aldukturah fi alhuquq kuliyat alhuquq -jamieat alqahirat 2010

aldawriaat:

• 'ahmad aldalaeini, du. safa' mahmud alsuwilimiiyn, alwisatat alqadayiyat kawasilat badilat lihali almunazaeat al'iidariati, dirasat muqaranati, majalat kuliyat alqanun alkuaytiat alealamiat - alsanat aleashirat - aleadad 1 - aleadad altasalsulii 37 - rabie althaani/ jamadaa al'uwlaa 1443 hi - disambir 2021 mi.
• 'ahmad sidqi mahmud, almudaeaa ealayh wazahirat albut' fi altaqadi ", majalat alsharieat walqanuni, aleadad (10), kuliyat alqanun jamieat al'iimarat alearabiat almutahidati, madinat aleayn, 'iimarat 'abu zabi al'iimarat alearabiat almutahidata, disambir, 1996.
• 'amal lutfi jab allah : alwisatat waltawfiq kawasayil hadithat lifadi almunazaeat al'iidariat dirasat muqaranati: majalat huquq hulwan lildirasat alqanuniat walaiqtisadiat eam 2015 eadad 33.
• tirari thani mustafaa, alwisatat katariq lihali alkhilafat fi zili qanun al'iijra'at almadaniat w al'iidariat aljadid, majalat almahkamat aleulya, eadad khasun hawl alturuq albadilat lihali alnizaeat alwisatat w alsulh w altahkimu, aljuz' althaani qism alwathayiqi, aljazayir 2009.
• eadil salim muhamad alluwzi, alwisatat litaswiat alnizaeat almadaniat wfqaan lilqanun al'urduniyi ", majalat mutat lilbuhuth w almadarisati, almujalad (21), aleadad (2) silsilat aleulum al'iinsaniat walaijtimaeiati, markaz dia' lilmutamarat wal'abhath madinat mutat, muhafazat alkarka, eaman, al'urdun, yunyu, 2006.
• eabd alhamid mahmud 'ahmadu, alwisatat kawasilat badilat litaswiat almunazaeat al'iidariati: dirasat muqaranati, majalat albuhuth alqanuniat walaiqtisadiati, jamieat almansurati, aleadad 83, 2021.
• eabd alsaduq khayra. alwisatat alqadayiyat fi altashrie aljazayiri-difatar alsiyasat walqanunu, jamieat abn khaldun tayart (aljazayir). -aleadad alraabie yanayir 2011 .
• eabd allah eabd alrahman aljanahi alkhatib: mabda alsiriyat fi 'iijra'at altaswiat alwudiyat lilmunazaeat ", majalat al'amn walqanun almujalad (23), aleadad (1), 'akadimiat shurtat dibi, 'iimarat dabaa al'iimarat alearabiat almutahidati, yulyu, 2015 m .
• eamar biwdyafi, almieyar almawduei wa'iishkalatih alqanuniat fi daw' qanun al'iijra'at almadaniat wal'iidaria ", majalat dafatir alsiyasat walqanuni, aleadad (5) kuliyat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiati, jamieat qasidi mirbah biwraqlatin, wilayat waraqlat aljazayar, yunyu, 2011.
• sahar eabd almuneam, alwisatat kabadil liltaqadi fi almunazaeat al'iidariati, almajalat almisriat lilqanun aleami, aleadad 12, 2019.
• alqadaa zilfa alhasan - maqalat muqadimat lilmutamar alraabie liltahkim alhandasaa almuqam faa alfatrat min 14 'iilaa 15 maris 2009 - alaitihad aleurbaa limarakiz altahkim alhandasaa bieunwani: (wasayil fadi alnizaeat tibqan lilfidik.
• tariq eabd aleali, falsafat almunazaeat al'iidariat wahudud altaswiat alwudiyat fi alqanun almisrii, majalat alfikr alqanunii almueasiri, aleadad 4, 2022.
• muhamad husayn, alwisatat ka'adat lihali almunazaeat al'iidariati, almajalat alqanuniati, aleadad 25, 2019.
• muhamad alsayid fawzi eamar:'ahimiyat alwisatat kawasilat widiyat silmiat litaswiat almunazaeat al'iidariati-majalat albuhuth alqanuniat walaiqtisadiat bikuliyat alhuquq jamieat almanufiat -eadad mayu 2023 almujalad 57 aleadad 3.
• muhamad eabdaleal 'iibrahim , alwisatat fi almunazaeat al'iidariat : dirasat li'ahkam nizam alwisatat fi alwisatat al'iidariat alfaransiati- majalat kuliyat alhuquq lilbuhuth alqanuniat walaiqtisadiat 2019.
• mnir mahmud biduaa :majala "dirasat mustaqbaliatun" , markaz dirasat almustaqbal - jamieat 'asyut - ja.mu.e alwisatat wadawr altraf althaalith fi taswiat almunazaeat aleadad althaamin (yulyu 2003)

altaqarir:

• munazamat al'amn waltaeawun al'uwrubiyati, almudawanat alqanuniat lihuquq almuhakamat aleadilat waldawliati, maktab almuasasat aldiymuqratiat wahuquq al'iinsan al'uwrubiy, warsu, bulanda, 'uktubar 2013.

alqawanin:

• qanun aliastithmar raqm 72 lisanat 2017"'ahdath taedil bitarikh 'awal 'aghustus 2019 bialqanun 141 lisanat 2019"

https://manshurat.org/node/14680#

• qanun al'iijra'at almadaniat wal'iidariat alsaadir fi 2008/02/25 raqm 09-08 aljarid alrasmiat eadad23/21 'abril 2008.
• qanun tanzim almunaqasat walmuzayadat raqm 89 lisanat 1998 alsaadir bitarikh 8 / 5 / 1998 walmanshur bialjaridat alrasmiat fi 8 / 5 / 1998.
• alqanun raqm 182 lisanat 2018 bi'iisdar qanun tanzim altaeaqudat alati tubrimuha aljihat aleamat aljaridat alrasmiat - aleadad 39 mukarir (da) fi 13 'uktubar sanat 2018.
• alqanun raqm 67 lisanat 2010 bi'iisdar qanun tanzim musharakat alqitae alkhasi faa mashrueat albinyat al'asasiat walkhadamat walmarafiq aleamati.
• qanun majlis aldawlat almisriu raqm 47 lisanat 1972.

alwathayiq:

• aljaridat alrasmiati, aleadadu21 tabie- tarikh alnashri: 22 mayu 2008 tarikh aleamal bihi: 1 'uktubar 2008.
• aljaridat alrasmiat - aleadad 19 mukarir ( a ) fi 18 mayu sanat 2010.
• jaridat alwaqayie aleiraqiat aleadad 4075 bitarikh 2008/5/19.

'ahkam almahakim w alqawanin:

• aldalil alqanuniu lilajnat al'umam almutahidat lilqanun altijarii alduwalii bishan siaghat aleuqud alduwaliat litashyid alminshat alsinaeia (aljuz' althaani), (aliunistiral) sadar fi niuyurk 1988 (al'umam almutahidati)
• alluwrd alqadi, rayiys qudaat 'iinjiltira wawilza, fi almutamar alwatanii althaalith limajlis alwisatat almadaniati, landan, 14 mayu 2009. mutah ealaa www.civilmediation.org
• hakum mahkamat baris aliastinafiat fi alqadiat CAA de PARIS, 2 decembre 2019, N° 19PA01967, 8eme chambre Inedit au recueil Lebon.
• qarar majlis aldawlat alfaransiu CE., 14 june 2018, N° 408265, 6eme et 5eme chambres reunies JurisData n° 2018-010737.
• qawaeid jameiat altahkim al'amrikiat lilwisata (AAA Mediation Rules 1996), walmarkaz alduwlaa lifadi alnizae (ICDR : international Centre for Dispute Resolution) waltaabieat lijameiat altahkim al'amrikia (AAA), wanzur mahkamat landan liltahkim altujaraa alduwlaa (LCIA : London Court of Arbitration)

alrawabit walmawaqie aliaktirunia:

• aldalil alqanuniu lilajnat al'umam almutahidat lilqanun altijarii alduwalii bishan siaghat aleuqud alduwaliat litashyid alminshat alsinaeia (aljuz' althaani), (aliunistiral) sadar faa niuyurk 1988 (al'umam almutahidati).
• qawaeid al'uwnsitral lilwisata (2021)