المقارنات الاجتماعية للمراهقين مستخدمي تطبيق الإنستجرام وعلاقتها بالتمرد النفسي والتطلعات المادية لديهم | ||
| مجلة البحوث الإعلامية | ||
| Volume 76, Issue 3, October 2025, Pages 1695-1788 PDF (14.02 M) | ||
| Document Type: المقالة الأصلية | ||
| DOI: 10.21608/jsb.2025.421600.1975 | ||
| Author | ||
| إنجي حلمي* | ||
| كلية التربية النوعية - جامعة المنصورة | ||
| Abstract | ||
| استهدفت الدراسة التعرف على العلاقة بين المقارنة الاجتماعية للمراهقين مستخدمي تطبيق إنستجرام والتمرد النفسي والتطلعات المادية لديهم، وذلك بالتطبيق على عينة عمدية قوامها (350) مفردة من طلاب وطالبات مرحلة المراهقة المتوسطة بالتعليم الثانوي، وطلاب وطالبات المراهقة المتأخرة بالتعليم الجامعي، وبلغت عينة مجموعات النقاش المركزة (18) طالبًا، واعتمدت الدراسة على منهج المسح الإعلامي والمنهج المقارن والمنهج الكيفي لمعالجة البيانات النوعية لنتائج جلسات مجموعات النقاش، واستخدمت الباحثة الاستبانة ومجموعات النقاش المركزة لجمع بيانات الدراسة الكمية والكيفية. وأظهرت نتائج الدراسة وجود علاقة ارتباطية ذات دلالة إحصائية بين كثافة استخدام المراهقين عينة الدراسة لتطبيق إنستجرام والمقارنة الاجتماعية والتمرد النفسي والتطلعات المادية لديهم، ووجود علاقة ارتباطية ذات دلالة إحصائية بين كلٍ من المقارنة الاجتماعية والتمرد النفسي والتطلعات المادية للمراهقين مستخدمي تطبيق إنستجرام، ووجود تأثير إيجابي دال إحصائيًا لكل من (المقارنة الاجتماعية - التطلعات المادية) في التمرد النفسي الناتج عن استخدام المراهقين لتطبيق إنستجرام. | ||
| Keywords | ||
| تطبيق إنستجرام; المقارنات الاجتماعية; التمرد النفسي; التطلعات المادية; المراهقين | ||
| References | ||
|
Simon Kemp. "Digital 2024: 5 billion social media users", 2024, Available on the website ,https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2024/01/digital-2024-5-billion-social-media-users/, visit in 10-1-2025, in 10:00 pm. [1]( Desirée Schmuck, Kathrin Karsay, Jörg Matthes, and Anja Stevic. "Looking Up and Feeling Down: The influence of mobile social networking site use on upward social comparison, self-esteem, and well-being of adult smartphone users", Telematics and Informatics, vol. (42), 2019, P2. [1] (Erin A. Vogel, Jason P. Rose, Lindsay R. Roberts, and Katheryn Eckles. "Social Comparison, social media, and Self-Esteem", Psychology of Popular Media Culture, vol. (3), No. (4), 2014, P 207. -Al-Sabab, A. (2011). "qyas altamarud alnafsii eind talbat maehad 'iiedad almuealimina", majalat jamieat Samara', 27(2). -Abu Hadrous, Y. (2010). "taqnin miqyas altamarud alnafsii ladaa almurahiqin ealaa albiyat alfilastiniati", majalat aleulum altarbawiat walnafsiati, 3(2). [1] (Andika Bramastha, Panca Kursistin, and dan Ria Wiyatfi. "Gambaran Social Comparison Pengguna Fitur Instastory pada Aplikasi Instagram di Kalangan Mahasiswa", Jurnal Psikologi, vol. (1), No. (2), 2024, Pp 1-9. [1]( Vidyawati. "Exploring the Relationship Between Instagram Use and Body Image Issues Among Teenagers", Mahogany Journal De Social, vol. (1), Issue. (2), 2024, Pp 65-70. [1] (Raphael Aubry, Alain Quiamzade, and Laurenz L. Meier. "Depressive symptoms and upward social comparisons during Instagram use: A vicious circle", Personality and Individual Differences, vol. (217), 2024, Pp 1-11. [1] (Nila Audini Oktavia, IGAA Noviekayati, and Dyan Evita Santi. "The Impact of Social Media Intensity on Body Dissatisfaction as Mediated by Social Comparison", Sinergi International Journal of Psychology, vol. (1), Issue. (3), 2023, Pp 131-141. - Alhadi, W. (2023). "almuqaranat aliajtimaeiat ealaa mawaqie altawasul aliajtimaeii: tathir astikhdam almar'at almisriat limawaqie altawasul aliajtimaeii ealaa suratiha nahw jasadiha wataqdiriha lidhatiha", almajalat Almisriat libuhuth al'iielami, 84(2). 89 - 159. [1] (Rehan M. Yahya, Dilan Ciftci, and Aytekin İŞMAN. "The Relationship between Social Media Exposure and Social Comparison Level: Instagram as a Model", The Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology, vol. (22), Issue. (2), 2023, Pp 131-149. [1] (Lara Schreurs, Adrian Meier, and Laura Vandenbosch. "Exposure to the Positivity Bias and Adolescents’ Differential Longitudinal Links with Social Comparison, Inspiration and Envy Depending on Social Media Literacy", Current Psychology, vol. (42), No. (32),2023, Pp 28221-28241. [1] (Laura Villanueva-Moya, M. Carmen Herrera, M. Dolores Sanchez-Hern andez, and Francisca Expósito. "#Instacomparison: Social Comparison and Envy as Correlates of Exposure to Instagram and Cyberbullying Perpetration", Psychological Reports, vol. (126), No. (3), 2022, Pp 1284-1304. - 'Ibrahim, S. (2021). "tathir astikhdam alshabab litatbiq al'iinistijram ealaa mustawaa almuqaranat aliajtimaeiat ladayhim", almajalat alearabiat libuhuth alaelam waliatisali, 34 (2), 456 - 510. -Al-Samti, S. (2021). "alsuwrat alnamatiat almutadawalat lilmujtamae alsaeudii ean tariq almuqaranat aliajtimaeiat mae almujtamaeat al'ukhraa", majalat aleulum al'iinsaniati, 12 (5), 79 - 101. - Mansur, H. (2021). "alealaqat bayn tasafuh suar mawaqie altawasul aliaijtimaeii walmuqaranat aliajtimaeiat ladaa almutasafihin alsueudiiyna", almajalat alearabiat lil'iielam waliatisali, 27 (2), 95 - 146. [1] (Delia Cristina, Dorin Spoaller. "How Social Comparison on Instagram Affects Well-Being", Perspectives from a Study Conducted During the Lockdown, vol. (65), No. (2), 2020, Pp 5-19. [1] (M. Scully, Lorraine Swords, and Elizabeth Nixon. "Social comparisons on social media: online appearance-related activity and body dissatisfaction in adolescent girls", Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine, vol. (40), No. (1), 2020, Pp 1-12. - Albarkati, M. (2019). "almuqaranat aliaijtimaeiat ealaa mawaqie altawasul aliajtimaeii waealaqatiha bi'aerad alaiktiaab ladaa eayinat min alfatayat bialmintaqat algharbiat bialmamlakat alearabiat alsueudiati", majalat al'iirshad alnafsi, 58 (2), 205 - 224. [1] (Katerina Lup, Leora Trub, and Lisa Rosenthal. "instagram #Instasad?: Exploring Associations Among Instagram Use, Depressive Symptoms, Negative Social Comparison, and Strangers Followed", Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, vol. (18), No. (5), 2015, Pp 247- 252. -Al-Sayed, H. (2025). "barnamaj arshadiun qayim ealaa maharat altafkir al'iijabii fi khafd hidat altamarud alnafsii ladaa eayinat min almurahiqina", majalat albahth aleilmii fi altarbiati, 4(2). 1: 37. - Amin, H. (2023). "al'iidha' alsaybiraniu eabr minasaat altawasul aliaijtimaeii kamuashir tanbiiy liltamarud alnafsii alsalbii walhashashat alnafsiat ladaa talbat jamieat 'um alquraa", majalat aljamieat al'iislamiat lildirasat altarbawiat walnafsiati, 5(2). 205 -234. [1] (Mohammed Y. Haggag. "Effects of demographic variables on rebellion and psychological status of football players", Journal of Sport Sciences and Physical Education, vol. (13), No. (1), 2023, Pp 21-31. [1](Ying Wang. "The Rebellious Psychology of College Students Based on Psychological Needs in Ideological Education and Its Correction", 3rd Annual Conference of Education, Teaching and Learning, 2022, Pp 101-106. -Mawloud, K. (2022)." altamarud alnafsiu waealaqatuh bisuluk aleunf ladaa talabih maehad eulum watiqniaat alnashatat albadaniati, majalat aleulum al'iinsaniati, 2(3). 345 - 353. -Abbas, E. (2021). "'uhadiat - taeadudiat alruwyat waealaqatiha bialtamarud alnafsii wasimat alshakhsiat ladaa talabat aljamieati", majalat albuhuth altarbawiat walnafsiati, 68(2). 451 - 488. - Alshaykh, Z. (2020). "altamarud alnafsii waealaqatuh bisuluk aleunf ladaa talbat maehad eulum watiqniaat alnashatat albadaniati", risalat majistir ghayr manshuratin, (jamieat Kasdi Merbah Wariqlata: maehad eulum watiqniaat alnashatat albadaniat walriyadiati, 2020). -Asaf, N. (2020). "qyas mustawaa altamarud alnafsii fi almadaris althaanawiat min wijhat nazar almadarisina", majalat jamieat Babli, 3(1). 240 - 258. [1] (Maha Abdel, Omar Abdel. "Characteristics of rebellious adolescent student drawings", International Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change, vol. (8), Issue. (10), 2019, Pp 343-358. -Ahmed, A. (2019). "mumarasat 'anshitat al'iielam almadrasii waltamarud alnafsii ladaa almurahiqina", almajalat alearabiat libuhuth al'iielam waliatisali, 26(1). 216 - 240. -Nabar, R. (2018)."mustawaa altamarud alnafsii ladaa talabat aljamieati", majalat albahith fi aleulum al'iinsaniat waliajtimaeiati, 35(2). 919 - 930. [1] (Thomashley S. Ganiron, Prinnah Fajardo, Paul Andrei, and Mervin Barcelona. "Evaluating the Factors Affecting High School Student Rebellion", The Scientific World Journal, 2017, Pp 158-176. - Zaki, H. (2014). 'ashraf rajab euta." muqawimat al'iighra' waltamarud alnafsii lilmurahiqin waealaqatihima bitaearudihim lilmusalsalat al'ajnabiat almudablajat fi alqanawat alfadayiyat Almisriati", majalat kuliyat altarbiati, 2(3), 321 - 407. -Bashir, F. (2012)." altamrud waealaqatuh bi'usalib almueamalat alwaldin ladaa talbat jamieit Al'azhar bighazata", risalat majistir ghayr manshuratin, (jamieat Al'azhar bi Gaza: kuliyat altarbiati). - Zidan, N. (2007) " qias altamarud alnafsii ladaa talabat almarhalat al'iiedadiati", majalat altarbiat waleilmi, 3 (3), 302 -318. [1] (Ivana Ondrijova. "Gender and Age Differences in Consumer Materialism", Technium Business and Management, vol. (10), 2024, Pp138-144. [1] (Arif Jameel, Sania Khan, Wadi B Alonazi, and Ali Ahmed Khan. "Exploring the Impact of Social Media Sites on Compulsive Shopping Behavior: The Mediating Role of Materialism", Psychology Research and Behavior Management, vol. (17), 2024, Pp171-185. -Al-Dessouki, H. (2023)." taerad al'atfal almisriiyn li'iielanat almuathirin eabr shabakat altawasul aliajtimaeii waealaqatih bimustawaa altatalueat almadiyat ladayhim", majalat albuhuth al'iielamiati, 66(2). 1547 - 1612. [1] (Daniel Tan Lei Shek, Kim Hung Leung, Diya Dou, and Xiaoqin Zhu. "Impact of Family Functioning on Adolescent Materialism and Egocentrism in Mainland China: Positive Youth Development Attributes as a Mediator", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. (19), No. (17), 2022, Pp1-20. [1](Anna Maria, Agnes Nairn, Tina M Lowrey, Liselot Hudders, Aysen Bakir, Andrew Rogers, Verolien Cauberghe, Elodie Gentina, Hua Li, and Fiona Spotswood. "Can the youth materialism scale be used across different countries and cultures? ", International Journal of Market Research, vol. (63), No. (3), 2021, Pp 317-334. [1] (Monali Neve, Rahul Trivedi. "Materialism and Media Usage: To study the role of media in increasing materialism among youths with special reference to social media exposure", International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology, vol. (290(, No. (8s), 2020, Pp 2431-2436. [1] (Alanna Zhang, Jamie Kennedy. "I Want It, Too: A Correlational Study on the Link Between Youth Celebrity Idolization and Materialism", Journal of Student Research, vol. (9), Issue. (2), 2020, Pp 1-21. [1](Janos Debrecen, Agnes Hofmeister. "Materialism among teenagers, the relationship between terminal values and social media use", International journal of multidisciplinarity in business and science, vol. (4), No. (5), 2018, Pp 5-12. [1] (Manisha Behal, Pavleen Soni. "Media Use and Materialism: A Comparative Study of Impact of Television Exposure and Internet Indulgence on Young Adults", Management and Labour Studies, vol. (43), Issue. (4), 2018, Pp 247-262. - Belhaj, T. (2017)." al'iielan wadawrih fi taeziz alqiam almadiyat watakhfid alrida ean alhayaati: dirasat ealaa eayinat min tulaab aljamieat bi Aljazayr", majalat milaf lilbuhuth waldirasati, 1(2), 5-38. [1] (Tahir Islam, Zaryab Sheikh, Zahid Hameed, Ikram Ullah Khan, and Rauf I. "Azam. Social comparison, materialism, and compulsive buying based on stimulusresponse model: a comparative study among adolescents and young adults", Young Consumers Insight and Ideas for Responsible Marketers, vol. (19), No. (1), 2018, Pp 19 - 37. [1] (Suzanna Johanna Opree, Rinaldo Kühne. "Generation Me in the Spotlight: Linking Reality TV to Materialism, Entitlement, and Narcissism", Mass Communication and Society, vol. (19), Issue. (6), 2016, Pp 800-819. [1] (Lisbeth Ku. "Development of Materialism in Adolescence: The Longitudinal Role of Life Satisfaction Among Chinese Youths", Social Indicators Research, vol. (124), Issue. (1), 2015, Pp 231-247. [1] (Carrie La Ferle, Kara Chan. "Determinants for materialism among adolescents in Singapore", Young Consumers Insight and Ideas for Responsible Marketers ,vol. (9), No. (3), 2008, Pp 201-214. [1](Kara Chan, Gerard P Prendergast. "Social comparison, imitation of celebrity models and materialism among Chinese youth", International Journal of Advertising, vol. (27), No. (5), 2008, Pp 799-826. [1] (Kara Chan, Gerard Prendergast. "Materialism and Social Comparison among Adolescents", Social Behavior and Personality an International Journal, vol. (35), No. (2), 2007, Pp 213-228. [1] (Bettina F. Piko. "Satisfaction with Life, Psychosocial Health and Materialism among Hungarian Youth", Journal of Health Psychology, vol. (11), No. (6), Pp 827-831. - Muhammadm O. (2024). " wasayil altawasul aliajtimaeii waealaqatiha bitajmil aliadtirabat alnafsiat - 'iinistijram nmwdhjan", majalat albuhuth al'iielamiati, 70 (2), 1199 - 1262. -Al-Mutairi, A. (2024)." aistikhdamat alsaeudiiyn liminasaat altawasul aliajtimaeii: al'iinistijram nmwdhjan", almajalat alearabiat lil'iielam waliatisali, 37 (2), 127 - 166. - Muhammad, H. (2023)" muqawamat althara' al'iielamii fi muhtawaa hisabat almuathirin fi alwatan alearabii ealaa shabakat al'iinistijram waealaqatiha bi'anmat altafaeuliati", almajalat aleilmiat libuhuth al'iidhaeat waltilifizyuni, 25 (2), 1 - 43. - Alhadi, W. (2022). "astikhdamat mawaqie altawasul aliajtimaeii waealaqatiha bimustawaa alshueur bialiaktiaab walwahdat alnafsiat ladaa alshabab almisrii", almajalat almisriat libuhuth al'iielami, 79 (3), 1 - 47. -Abdel-Baqi, O. (2022). "tasawurat alshabab almisrii bishan ainistijram kamasdar lilhusul ealaa al'akhbar walmaelumat wa'athar dhalik ealaa tabieat aistikhdamihim lihi", almajalat aleilmiat libuhuth alsahafati, 24(1). -Othman, S. (2021)." alealaqat bayn mutabaeat alshabab limawqie al'iinistijram watanmiat maharatihim aliajtimaeiati", almajalat Almisriat libuhuth alraay aleami, 2(4). 423 - 477. -Abdel Fattah, M. (2021)." aleawamil alkhamsat alkubraa lilshakhsiat waealaqatiha biaistikhdam aljumhur almisrii litatbiq al'iinistijrami", almajalat Almisria libuhuth alraay aleami, 2(4). 263 - 305. [1] (Shaohai Jiang, Annabel Ngien. "The Effects of Instagram Use, Social Comparison, and Self-Esteem on Social Anxiety: A Survey Study in Singapore", Social Media + Society, vol. (6), No. (2), 2020, Pp 1-10. [1] (Popy Prilyantinasari, Ahmad Mulyana. "The Effect of Instagram Exposure of Hedonic Lifestyle on Dissonance Rates for Digital Native", International Journal of English, Literature and Social Sciences, vol. (5), Issue. (2), 2020, Pp 396-402. [1] (Zoe Brown, Marika Tiggemann. "A picture is worth a thousand words: The effect of viewing celebrity Instagram images with disclaimer and body positive captions on women’s body image", Body Image, vol. (33), Issue. (2), 2020, Pp190-198. [1] (Ha Sung. "Why Social Comparison on Instagram Matters: Its impact on Depression", KSII Transactions on Internet and Information Systems, vol. (13), No. (3), 2019, Pp 1626-1638. [1]( Samantha B Mackson, Paula M Brochu, and Barry A Schneider. "Instagram: Friend or foe? The application’s association with psychological well-being", new media & society, vol. (21), No. (10), 2019, Pp 2160-2182. [1] (Ali J. Al-Kandari, Ahmed A. Al-Hunaiyyan, and Rana Al-Hajri. "The Influence of Culture on Instagram Use", Journal of Advances in Information Technology, vol. (7), No. (1), 2016, Pp 54-57. [1]( https://www.searchenginejournal.com/instagram-facts/314439/, visit in 10-6-2025, in 10:20 pm. -Mu’ayyad, H. (2024). "alealaqat bayn alsimat alshakhsiat ladaya almurahiqin wastiratijiaat taqdim aldhaat eabr minasaat altawasul alaijtimaeii: dirasatan fi 'iitar aldawr alwasit litaqdir aldhaat walrida ean alhayaati", almajalat Almisria libuhuth alaitisal aljamahiri, 2(3).1653,1652. [1] (Leon Festinger. " A Theory of Social Comparison Processes", Human Relations, vol. (7), No. (2), 1954, P118. [1] (Pieternel Dijkstra, Frederick X. Gibbons, and Abraham P. Buunk. "Social comparison theory, In Social Psychological Foundations of Clinical Psychology", Edited by James E. Maddux and June Price Tangney, (The Guilford Press, 2010), P 195. [1] (Jan Crusius, Katja Corcoran, and Thomas Mussweiler. "Social Comparison: A Review of Theory, Research, and Applications", Second Edition, 2022, P 2. [1](Dmitri Rozgonjuk, Tracii Ryan, Joosep Kristjan Kuljus, Karin Täht, and Graham G. Scott. "Social comparison orientation mediates the relationship between [1] (Thomas Ashby. "Downward Comparison Principles in Social Psychology", Psychological Bulletin, vol. (90), No. (2), 1981, P245. [1] (Jack Williams Brehm. "A theory of psychological reactance", (New York, Academic Press, 1966), Pp1:2. [1] (Benjamin D. Rosenberg, Jason T. Siegel. "A 50-year review of psychological reactance theory: Do not read this article", Motivation Science, vol. (4), No. (4), 2018, P 2. http://tfpb.org/pic/arabic-hal-niza3at.pdf, visit in 15-7-2025, in 11:00 pm. [1](Morty Bernstein, Faye Crosby. "An empirical examination of relative deprivation theory", Journal of experimental social psychology, vol. (16),1980, P443. [1](Heather J. Smith, Thomas F. Pettigrew, Gina M. Pippin, and Silvana Bialosiewicz. " Relative Deprivation: A Theoretical and Meta Analytic Review", Personality and Social Psychology Review, vol. (16), No. (3),2012, P 203. [1] (Simone I. Flynn. "Relative Deprivation Theory, Sociology Reference Guide", Theories of social movements, 1Ed, (California: Salem Press,2011), P101:102. [1](Eman Alaslani. "Insta - Tweet Appeal among Saudi Women: A Uses-and gratifications Perspective", Unpublished master thesis, (St. Mary’s University: Faculty of the Graduate School ,2019), P 3. [1] (Nicole Dion. "The Effect of Instagram on Self-Esteem and Life Satisfaction", Honors Thesis For the Degree of Bachelor of Science in Psychology, (Salem State University: College of Arts and Sciences, 2015), P6. - Zahran, H. (2005). "ealam nafs alnumui (altufulat walmurahaqati)" Alqahira, t 6, ( Alam alkutub). [1] (Laurel Steinfield. "Rethinking Materialism: A Question of Judgements and Enactments of Power", Unpublished Ph. D thesis, (University of Oxford: Green Templeton College,2016), P 1. [1](Suzanna J. Opree, Moniek Buijzen, Eva A. van Reijmersdal, and Patti M. Valkenburg. "Development and validation of the Material Values Scale for children", The 10th ICORIA Berlin conference, 2011, P1. -Aparna Sharma, Kavish Sanghvi, and Prathamesh Churi. "The impact of Instagram on young Adult’s social comparison, colourism and mental health: Indian perspective", International Journal of Information Management Data Insights, vol. (12), 2022, P8. - Fadili, M. (2022). "altamarud alnafsii waltashawuhat almaerifiat kamunabiyiyn bialaiktiaab ladaa talabat aljamieat mudmini mawaqie altawasul alaijtimaeii fi dawlat alkuayti", risalat majistir ghayr manshuratin, (jamieat Al'iiskandaria: kuliyat altarbiati. - Abdul Zahr, S., Dawud, F. (2018). "surat aldhaat aleamat waealaqatuha bialtamarud alnafsii ladaa talbat marhalat aldirasat almutawasitati", majalat 'abhath albasrat lileulum al'iinsaniati, 1(2). 45 : 47. -Manisha Behal, Pavleen Soni. "The mediating role of parental mediation in the relationship between media use and materialism", International Journal of Business Innovation and Research, vol. (23), No. (3), 2020, Pp 296: 297. [1](https://www.youm7.com/story/2024/8/23/%D8%A3%D8%B1%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%AA%D9%83%D8%B4%D9%81-%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%A8-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%AF%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A5%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%AC%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%81%D9%89-%D9%85%D8%B5%D8%B1-2024/6683628, visit in 19-6-2025, in 12:10 pm. [1]( Haoyue Yuan. "Effects of Social Media on Teenagers’ Mental Health", Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, vol.(653), 2022, P 1069.
| ||
|
Statistics Article View: 3 |
||