NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES
Hanna, M. (2021). NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES. EKB Journal Management System, 6(2), 212-232. doi: 10.21608/jguaa2.2021.58863.1049
Monica Hanna. "NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES". EKB Journal Management System, 6, 2, 2021, 212-232. doi: 10.21608/jguaa2.2021.58863.1049
Hanna, M. (2021). 'NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES', EKB Journal Management System, 6(2), pp. 212-232. doi: 10.21608/jguaa2.2021.58863.1049
Hanna, M. NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES. EKB Journal Management System, 2021; 6(2): 212-232. doi: 10.21608/jguaa2.2021.58863.1049

NOTE ON THE RESTORATION OF FIVE EGYPTIAN MOSQUES

Journal of the General Union of Arab Archaeologists
Article 11, Volume 6, Issue 2, May 2021, Page 212-232  XML PDF (5.95 MB)
Document Type: Original Article
DOI: 10.21608/jguaa2.2021.58863.1049
View on SCiNiTO View on SCiNiTO
Author
Monica Hanna email orcid
Acting Dean, College of Archaeology and Cultural Heritage the Arab Academy for Science, Technology and Maritime Transport, Egypt
Abstract
 (Ar)
ملاحظات على ترميم خمسة مساجد مصرية
يناقش هذا البحث الخسارة الثقافية لخمسة مساجد مصرية في أقاليم مصر نتيجة عمليات الترميم بها يضم البحث السجلات التاريخية المختلفة التي وصفت أهمية تلك المساجد وكيف أن الترميم الحديث قضى على الكثير من تفاصيلها التاريخية. يوضح البحث من وجهة نظر ادارة التراث غياب التنسيق بين وزارة الأوقاف ووزارة الآثار والسياحة لعمليات الترميم التي تتم للتجديد وليس للترميم بهذه المساجد التاريخية، هذا لا يؤثر فقط على التراث الإسلامي لريف مصر، بل يؤثر أيضًا على النسيج العمراني حول تلك المساجد. تناقش هذه الورقة مساجد المتولي في جرجا، قمن
.العروس في بني سويف، المحلي وزغلول في رشيد
 
(En) This paper discusses the cultural loss of five Egyptian mosques in Egypt due to their renovation. While illicit digging, encroachment, and real estate unplanned development has damaged ancient Egyptian heritage, in particular in the last eleven years, Egypt has a long history of faulty restorations of Islamic monuments, which include demolition, wholesome reconstruction, and unhistorical additions. Few of the original early Islamic monuments survive today, the oldest being the Nilometer on Rawḍa Island (869 AD), which dates to two hundred years after the Arab conquest of Egypt. Interventions in the capital Cairo are often subjected to media coverage and the scrutiny of the public, but in the provinces, violations are widespread and many botched restorations go virtually unnoticed. This paper discusses five Egyptian provincial mosques whose more or less recent restoration has had catastrophic results on the original buildings: al-Mitwally mosque in Čirǧā (Sūhaǧ), Qimn al-ʿArūs mosque (Bāni Sūayf), Zaġhlūl and al-Maḥally mosques in Rāšid (Baḥayra), al-‘Amry mosque in Dumiyāt. The paper will briefly describe the appearance of these buildings, discuss their history based on the few primary (including historical photographs and accounts) and secondary sources (literature in English and Arabic), and report on an eyewitness survey of their current state carried out between 2018 and 2020, after restorations that have wiped away many of their intricate historic details. The lack of coordination between the Ministry of Endowments and the Ministry of Antiquities and Tourism has resulted in renovation instead of restoration for these mosques. This does not only affect the Islamic heritage of rural Egypt, but the urban fabric around those mosques accordingly. In the conclusions, the author proposes a way forward to overcome problems in the coordination and execution of restoration works and guarantee the functionality of the buildings for the communities they serve without damaging their historical features. First, the author proposes an implemented code as an addendum to the antiquities law that is enforced on all companies working in conservation. Secondarily, workshops carried out by various academic boards and the Ministry of Antiquities and Tourism should discuss the concept of authenticity and how this should codify all future heritage practices.
 

Highlights
  • Introduction
  • Al-Mitwally Mosque, Ğirǧā (Sūhaǧ)
  • Qimn Al-ʿarūs Mosque, Bani Sūaīf
  • Zaġhlūl Mosque, Rāšid
  • Al-Maḥally Mosque, Rāšid
  • Al-ʿamry Mosque, Dumiyāt
  • Conclusions

 

Keywords
Islamic heritage; Restoration; Mosques; Rāšid; Čirǧā; Dumiyāt
References
  • ʿABD AL-WAHHĀB, H.: «Ṭarz al-ʿimāra al-īslāmiya fy rīf Miṣr», Bulletin de l’Institut d’Egypte/Maǧallat al- Maǧmaʿ al-ʿIlmy al-Miṣry 38/2, 1956-57, 5-40.
  • AMIN, N.: The Historical Monuments of Egypt. Volume I: Rosetta, Cairo: (Supreme Council of Antiquities), 2008.
  • ALSAYYAD, N., BIERMAN, I.A., Rabbat, N.: Making Cairo Medieval, Lanham, Md: (Lexington), 2005. BAEDEKER, C.: Egypt: Handbook for Travellers. Part First, Lower Egypt, with the Fayuˆm and the Peninsula ofSinai, Leipzig-London: (Baedecker), 1885.
  • CRESWELL, K.A.C., «Jamiʾ ʿAmr ibn al-ʿAs», [photograph], Archnet, early 20th century, https://archnet.org/sites/4253/media_contents/33636, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • DU CAMP, M.: «Mosquée d’Ali-Bey, à Girgeh», [photograph] Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 1849-50a, https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/287097, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • DU CAMP, M.: «Vue de Girgeh et du littoral enlevé - par l’inondation du Nil», [photograph] Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 1849-50b, https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/287096, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • DUQEIL, H.: «Demolition of Egypt’s Heritage: Reality and Dangers», al-Maʿhd al-Misri al-Dirasat, 8 September 2020, https://en.eipss-eg.org/demolition-of-egypts-heritage-reality-and-dangers/, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • EDWARDS, A.: A Thousand Miles Up the Nile, London: (Routledge), 1877.
  • ELSHAHED, M.: «Demolitions and the Urgency of Architectural History in Egypt», Platform, 7 September 2020,https://www.platformspace.net/home/demolitions-and-the-urgency-of-architectural-history-in-egypt, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • HANNA, M.: «Documenting Looting Activities in post-2011 Egypt», In Countering Illicit Traffic in Cultural Goods. The global challenge of protecting the world’s heritage, 47-64. Paris: (ICOM), 2015.
  • HANNA, M.: «What has Happened to Egyptian Heritage after the 2011 Unfinished Revolution?» Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology & Heritage Studies 1, 4, 2013, 371-375.
  • HEMEDA, S., KHALIL, M., SHOEB, A., ABD EL AZIZ, A.: «The Effectiveness of Nano Materials and Nano-modified Polymers for Preservation of Historic Brick Masonry in Rashid, Egypt», International Journal of Conservation Science 9, 4, 2018, 844.
  • IKRAM, S., HANNA, M.: «Looting and Land Grabbing: The Current Situation in Egypt», Bulletin of the American Research Center in Egypt 202, 2013, 34-39.
  • «Inauguration of Amr Ibn El-Aas Mosque», The Arab Contractors, 10 May 2009, https://www.arabcont.com/English/Release-2009-385, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • «Inauguration of the Restoartion [sic] Works of Amr Ibn El-Aas Mosque», The Arab Contractors, 21 July 2009, https://www.arabcont.com/English/Release-2009-405, accessed on January 13, 2021.

  • JOLLOIS, M.: ‚Notice sur la ville de Rosette‛, in Description de l’Égypte ou Recueil des observations et des recherches qui ont été faites en Égypte pendant l'expédition de l'armée française, État moderne, t. 18, part 1, 497-554. Paris : (C.L.F. Panckoucke) 1826.

  • LANE, E.W.: Description of Egypt. Edited and with an introduction by Jason Thompson, Cairo-New York: (AUC Press), 2000.
  • MĀHIR, S.: Muḥāfaẓāt al-Ǧumhūriya al-ʿArabiya al-muttaḥida wa āṯāruhā al-bāqiya fy al-ʿaṣr al-īslāmy, Cairo: (al-Maǧlis al-Ālʿaly lil-Šuʾūn al-Īslāmiya), 1966.
  • MEINARDUS, O.: Two Thousand Years of Coptic Christianity, Cairo-New York: (AUC Press), 2002.
  • «Ministers of Awqaf and Antiquities inaugurated the 1st phase of the restoration and renovation of Zaghloul Archaeological Mosque», The Arab Contractors, 16 May 2018, https://www.arabcont.com/English/Release-2018-1231, accessed on January 13, 2021.
  • SANDERS, P.: Creating Medieval Cairo. Empire, Religion and Architectural Preservation in Nineteenth-Century Egypt, Cairo-New York: (AUC Press), 2008.
  • ʿUṮMĀN, M.: 1988. «Ǧirǧā wa aṯāruhā al-īslāmiya fy al-ʿaṣr al-ʿuṯmāny», Dirāsāt āthāriya al- īslāmiya/Islamic Archaeological Studies 3, 1988, 209-68.
Statistics
Article View: 402
PDF Download: 614