مطالبة النافي بالدليل | ||||
| مجلة قطاع الشريعة والقانون | ||||
| Article 10, Volume 14, Issue 14, 2023, Page 671-728 PDF (2.42 MB) | ||||
| Document Type: المقالة الأصلية | ||||
| DOI: 10.21608/jssl.2023.288456 | ||||
 View on SCiNiTO | ||||
| Author | ||||
| هدى السيد محمد المهدي | ||||
| قسم أصول الفقه، كلية الدراسات الإسلامية والعربية للبنات بالمنصورة، جامعة الأزهر، مدينة المنصورة، جمهورية مصر العربية. | ||||
| Abstract | ||||
| مطالبة النافي بالدليل من المسائل المختلف فيها بين الأصوليين، وقد وضعوا لها عناوين مختلفة مما أوقع في لبس وخلط بينها وبين مسائل أخرى كمسألة (الاستدلال بالعدم) ومسألة (استصحاب العدم الأصلي) فأردت الوقوف على حقيقة المسألة والأقوال الواردة فيها مرجحة ما رأيت أنه الصواب ومبينة العلاقة بينها وبين مثيلاتها. وقد اتبعت في هذا البحث المنهج الاستقرائي ثم التحليلي ثم الاستنباطي، فقد تتبعت أقوال العلماء في المسألة وذكرت أدلة كل فريق على ما ذهب إليه محررة محل النزاع ومقارنة بين أقوالهم حتى أصل لتأصيل هذه المسألة ، محاولة الالتزام بضوابط البحث العلمي وأسسه قدر الإمكان. وقد توصلت في نهاية البحث لعدد من النتائج، منها: أن حاصل الأقوال الواردة في المسألة يرجع إلى ثلاثة فقط ، الأول كون النافي مطالبا بالدليل في المسائل النظرية شريطة كونه يدعي العلم بالنفي لا نفي العلم ، والثاني عدم مطالبته بالدليل ، والثالث مطالبته بالدليل في نفي العقليات دون الشرعيات. وأن مدارك نفي الحكم الشرعي إما إجماع على النفي أو نص به أو قياس مع كون الجامع وجود مانع أو عدم شرط ، وأن مسألة الاستدلال بالعدم أخص من مسألة مطالبة النافي بالدليل ؛ إذ الاستدلال بالعدم أحد الأدلة التي قد يستدل بها على نفي الحكم ، وأنه لا يوجد اختلاف بين الاستصحاب والاستدلال بالعدم من حيث مؤدى كل منهما وإنما الاختلاف فقط في كيفية الاستدلال أو نهج المستدل ، وأن الاستدلال بالعدم حجة للنافي في حق الله تعالى وله أن يفتي به غيره ، ولا يكون حجة لأحد الخصمين على الآخر إذا لم يكن مما تتوفر الدواعي على نقله. Al-Nafi's claim to the evidence is one of the different issues among the fundamentalists, and they placed different titles for it, which confused it with other issues such as the issue (inference of nothingness) and the issue (elemental withdrawal). I wanted to know the truth of the issue and the statements contained therein, weighing what I thought was right and indicating the relationship between them and their peers. In this research, I followed the approach of induction, then analysis, then deduction. I followed the statements of scientists in the matter, and I mentioned the evidence of each team on what the editor at issue had said, and compared their statements until I reached the origin of this issue, an attempt to adhere to the rules of scientific research and its foundations as much as possible. At the end of the research, I came to a number of conclusions, including: The sum of the statements in the matter is due to only three; the first is that the denier is required to give evidence in theoretical matters, provided that he claims science to negate science, the second is not required to do so, and the third is his claim to proof in denying illegality. that the perception of the negation of the Shariah clause is either unanimous, stated or measured, with the Mosque having an objection or unconditional, and that the question of the inference of nullity is more important than the issue of the claim of the denier for evidence ; Inference by nullity is one of the evidences of a ruling's negation, and there is no difference between approval and inference by nullity in terms of their respective meaning, only difference in how the inference is based or the approach of the inference, and that inference by nullity is an argument against the truth of God Almighty and may be pronounced by others. | ||||
| Keywords | ||||
| النفي; الدليل; العدم; الاستدلال; الاستصحاب. Denial; Evidence; Nothingness; Inference; Companionship | ||||
| References | ||||
Source and reference list 1. Sinan Abi Daoud (T:275h), T: Modern Library, Saida - Beirut, Investigator: Dr. Mohamed Mohieddin Abdel Hamid.
2. Sinan Al-Tarmadi (C: 279 A.H.), I: Mustafa Al-Babi Al-Halabi Press - Egypt, second edition, 1395 A.H. - 1975 A.D., Investigation: Ahmed Mohammed Shaker (C1, 2), Mohamed Fouad Abdel Baqi (C3), and Ibrahim Atwa Awad (C4, 5).
3. Sinan Al-Darqati (385H), I: Al-Resala Foundation-Beirut, first edition 1424H-2004, An investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnout, Hasan Shalabi, Abdul Latif Harizallah, Ahmed Barhoum.
4. Sahih Al-Bukhari Al-Jamaa Al-Musnad Al-Saheem Al-Saheem from the matters of the Messenger of Allah, his age, and his days (T:256), T: Dar Tuq Al-Najat, first edition 1422 A.H., Investigation: Muhammad Zuhair Bin Nasser.
5. True Muslim Al-Musnad Al-Saheem, short for transferring justice from justice to the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him (T:261H), T: The Arab Heritage Revival House, Beirut, Investigator: Mohammed Fouad Abdel-Baqi.
6. Musnad Ahmad Bin Hanbal (T: 241H), I: Al-Resala Foundation, first edition 1421H-2001 A.D., investigator: Shuaib Al-Arnout - Adel Morshed, et al.
7. Al-Raya Monument to Proselytizing Conversations with Its Entourage in Al-Zilei's Graduation of Gamal Al-Din Abu Muhammad Abdullah Bin Yousef Bin Muhammad Al-Zilei (Deceased: 762H) Publisher: Al-Rayyan Printing and Publishing Foundation - Beirut-Lebanon/Dar Al-Qibla for Islamic Culture - Jeddah - Saudi Arabia, First Edition, 1418 H/1997, Investigator: Muhammad Awama
8. Courtesy of the Translation of the Proselytizing Speech by Father Al-Fadl Ahmad Bin Ali Bin Mohammed Bin Ahmed Bin Hajar Al-Asqlani (T:852H), publisher: Dar Al-Maarafa - Beirut, investigator: Mr. Abdullah Hashim Al-Yamani Al-Madani
9. Aid for the Doctrine of the City World "Imam Malik bin Anas" by Abd al-Wahab bin Ali bin Nasr al-Thalaabi al-Baghdadi al-Maliki (dead: 422h) Publisher: Commercial Library, Mustafa Ahmed al-Baz - Mecca, Investigator: Hamish Abd al-Haq, Origin of Book: A Doctoral Message at Umm al-Qura University in Mecca
10. The beginning of the diligent and the end of the frugal, the son of Rushid the Great (A.D. 595), Cairo, Dar Al-Hadith, 1425 A.H. - 2004.
11. Al-Sana'a' in the Law Order of Abi Bakr Bin Masoud Bin Ahmed Al-Kasani Al-Hanafi (T:587H), T: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamiya - Beirut, Second Edition 1406H - 1985M.
12. The building explained the gift to Mahmoud Bin Ahmed Bin Musa Al-Ghitabi Badreddine Al-Aini (T:855 AH), T: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamiya - Beirut, Lebanon, First edition, 1420 AH - 2000 AD.
13. Mother of Imam Al-Shafi'i (T: 204H), I: Dar Al-Maarfa - Beirut, 1410H/1990.
14. The facts are explained in the treasure trove of minutes by Uthman bin Ali Al-Zilali Al-Hanafi (T: 743H), and below the book is the footnote of Al-Shalabi by Shihab Al-Din Ahmed bin Mohammed bin Younis Al-Shalabi (T: 1021H), T: The Emiri Grand Printing House - Cairo, first edition 1313H.
15. Grand Hawi in the jurisprudence of the doctrine of the Shafi'i Imam Ali bin Muhammad bin Habib Al-Basri famous for Mawardi (T:450 AH), T: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamieh - Beirut, first edition, 1419 AH-1999 AD, Investigator: Sheik Ali Moawad - Sheik Adel Abd Al-Majud.
16. Total, polite explanation of Mohieddin Yahya bin Sharaf Al-Nawawi (T:676H), T: Dar Al-Fikr - Beirut. (With plumbing and obedience supplement).
17. Singer Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Mohammed bin Qudamah Al-Maqdisi Al-Hanbali (T:620 AH), Cairo Library, 1388 AH-1968 AD.
18. Al-Bayan, Al-Imam Al-Shafi'i, Abu Al-Hussein, Yahya Bin Abi Al-Khair Bin Salem Al-Amrani, Yemen (T: 558H), T: Dar Al-Minhaj, Jeddah, first edition 1421H-2000, Investigator: Qassim Mohammed Al-Nouri.
19. Al-Kafi in the jurisprudence of the people of the city Yusuf bin Abdullah bin Abdul Barr bin Asem Al-Nimri Al-Qurtubi (T:463 A.H.), T: Modern Riyadh Library-Saudi Arabia, second edition 1400 A.H.-1980 A.D., Investigator: Mohamed Ahid Ould Madek Al-Mauritani.
20. Care and Demonstration of the Gift to Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Mahmoud Akmal Al-Din Gamal Al-Rumi Al-Babarti (T: 786H), publisher: Dar Al-Fikr.
21. Chapter Tightening in Asset Judgments by Abi Walid Al-Baji, Investigation Dr. Abdullah Muhammad Al-Jubouri, Al-Resala Foundation (1409-1989)
22. Seif Eddin Al Amadi , Islamic Bureau.
23. Al-Hakam in the Origins of Al-Dhaheri's Son, Hadith.
24. Al-Fohol's Guidance for Realization of Truth from Al-Shokani's Archeology, Dr. Shaaban Muhammad Ismail's Investigation, Dar Al-Kitbi.
25. The reference in Knowledge of Origins and Licentiousness in the meaning of Guide to Beji, The Investigation of Muhammad Ali Farkas, I/Dar Al Bashayer Al Islamiyya.
26. The Origins of Al-Bazdawi in Explanation of Secrets Revelation , Modern Dar Al-Farouk Printing.
27. Al-Jassas' Origins Imam Abu Bakr Al-Razi, Investigation Dr. Mohammed Amer, I/Dar Al-Kubab Al-Alami.
28. The sea surrounding Zarkshi, achieving Dr. Omar Suleiman al-Ashqar.
29. Syndicate of mosques for Al-Zarkshi; Investigation of Dr. Said Abd Al-Aziz, Dr. Abdullah Rabih, and the Cordoba Foundation.
30. The illuminated planet explained to the carpenter's son Hanbali, A/Bibliotheca.
31. The crop in Al-Razi Asset Science, Dr. Taha Alwani Investigation, Imam Bin Saud University.
32. The lighted lamp at Ghareeb explains the Fayoumi, T/Modern Library, Sidon Beirut.
33. Ibn Faris' Linguistics Thesaurus, by Dr. Abdul-Salam Haroun, I/Dar al-Gel.
| ||||
|
Statistics Article View: 388 PDF Download: 279 |
||||
