الكارتلات الاحتكارية بين الفقه الإسلامي والنظام الرأسمالي | ||||
| مجلة قطاع الشريعة والقانون | ||||
| Article 14, Volume 14, Issue 14, 2023, Page 963-1062 PDF (2.46 MB) | ||||
| Document Type: المقالة الأصلية | ||||
| DOI: 10.21608/jssl.2023.288460 | ||||
 View on SCiNiTO | ||||
| Author | ||||
| أحمد قياتي محمد شلقامي | ||||
| قسم الفقه العام، كلية الشريعة والقانون بالقاهرة، جامعة الأزهر الشريف، مصر. | ||||
| Abstract | ||||
| تعرف الكارتلات الاحتكارية بأنها عبارة عن حلف احتكاري بين مجموعة من المنتجين في فرع واحد من فروع الإنتاج أو فروع متعددة، يخلصوا فيه من مضار المنافسة بينهم، كما يظلوا مستقلين عن بعضهم في الأمور التي لم يتناولها الاتفاق، وتعد الكارتلات الاحتكارية أسوء صور الاحتكار الحديث إذ يمتد أذاها إلى معظم الناس، كونها تستهدف أكبر ربح ممكن من جمهور المستهلكين دون النظر إلى مصالحهم، وبالتالي ترتكب الوسائل غير المشروعة في سبيل تحقيق ذلك كاستنزاف المواد الخام من البلاد النامية وعرقلة إنتاجهم وعدم السماح لهم بالظهور حتى تنفرد بالسوق وحدها، ومن خبث فعل بعض الكارتلات الاحتكارية أنها تلقي بفائضها الانتاجي في عرض البحر أو بإحراقه حفاظًا على مكانتها الاقتصادية، مما يتسبب في إلحاق الضرر بالمجتمعات، وإهلاك بعض البشر جوعًا نتيجة لنقصان السلع، والكارتلات الاحتكارية لا تقف على البيع والشراء بل تصل إلى احتكار الخدمة، ككارتلات التوكيلات الحصرية. والبحث تعرض لتأصيل الكارتلات الاحتكارية في ضوء نصوص الشريعة ومقاصدها، بالتخريج على نصوص الفقهاء مع تنقيح المناط، فتناول التكييف الفقهي والقانوني لها، والآثار الاقتصادية المتعلقة بالكارتلات الاحتكارية للمنتجين، والمستهلكين، والعمال، والتدابير الوقائية للسلطة لمواجهة الكارتلات الاحتكارية كما تعرض للوسائل العقابية التي تفرضها السلطة في مواجهتها، وخلص البحث في مجمله إلى تحريم الكارتلات من الناحية الشرعية وتجريمها من الناحية القانونية، لما لها من آثار سلبية عامة تمس كل الشرائح المجتمعية، ومن حق السلطة التدخل للحد من وجود الكارتلات الاحتكارية وقائيًا باستغلال مواردها وفق المقاصد الشرعية، وتخزين سلعها الضرورية وفق خطط زمنية، ومقاطعة منتجات الكارتلات، وعقابيًا بإعطاء صلاحيات أوسع لجهاز حماية المستهلك، وفرض التسعير الجبري للكارتلات الاحتكارية، وفرض عقوبة مالية رادعة لها، وتفكيكها وبيع السلع جبرًا عنها. Monopolistic cartels are defined as a monopoly alliance between a group of producers in one branch of production or multiple branches, in which they eliminate the effects of competition between them, as they remain independent in matters that were not covered by the agreement. Monopolistic cartels are the worst form of modern monopoly as they affect most people, as they target the largest possible profit from the consumer audience without regard for their interests. Illegal means are thus committed in order to achieve this, such as depleting raw materials from the developing countries, obstructing their production and not allowing them to appear until they are unique to the market alone. It is pernicious to some monopolistic cartels that they throw their production surplus at sea or burn it to preserve their economic status, causing damage to some societies and damage to sell, leading to the monopolization of goods, and the monopolization of others Service, such as exclusive agent cartels. Research has focused on the legalization of cartels and their legal revisions. It has addressed the jurisprudential and legal adaptation of cartels, the economic effects of cartels for producers, consumers and workers, preventive measures taken by the Authority to confront cartels, and punitive measures imposed by the Authority in confronting them. The research has concluded that cartels are legally prohibited and criminalized, as they have general negative effects on all segments of society. The Authority has the right to intervene to limit the existence of cartels and to exploit their resources in accordance with legitimate purposes, to store their necessary commodities according to time plans, to boycott cartel products, and to impose broader powers to protect consumers and impose penalties on them, as a form of punishment, as well as financial sanctions, and financial sanctions imposed on them dismantle them and forcibly sell the goods. | ||||
| Keywords | ||||
| الكارتلات الاحتكارية; عرقلة الإنتاج; حماية المستهلك; تفكيك الكارتلات; التجارة. : Cartels; disruption of production; consumer protection; break-up of cartels; trade | ||||
| References | ||||
|
أولاً: مراجع التفسير وعلوم القرآن:
ثانياً: كتب متون الحديث والآثار:
ثالثًا: شروح الحديث:
رابعًا: كتب الأصول والقواعد
خامسًا: كتب الفقه الفقه الحنفي
الفقه المالكي
الفقه الشافعي
الفقه الحنبلي
الفقه العام
مراجع اللغة، والاصطلاحات الفقهية:
مراجع عامة
Source and reference list First, references to interpretation and Qur'an science: 1. Qur'an Provisions, by Abi Bakr Ahmed Bin Ali, Al-Razi Al-Jasas Al-Hanafi, T:370H, T: Dar Al-Ittihad Al-Arabi, Beirut, Iqtifaq: Mohammed Sadeq Al-Qamhawi-member of the Al-Azhar Quran Review Committee. 2. Author: Abu Abdullah Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Abi Bakr bin Farah Al-Ansari Al-Khazraji Shams Al-Din Al-Qurtubi (Deceased: 671h) Investigation: Ahmed Al-Bardouni and Ibrahim Atfeish, publisher: Egyptian Dar Al-Kutub - Cairo. 3. Elected in Interpretation of the Holy Quran, p. 637, Author: Committee of Al-Azhar Scholars, Publisher: Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs - Egypt, Al-Ahram Institution Edition, 18 th edition, 1416 A.H.-1995 Part No. 1. 4. Facilitated interpretation, for a number of interpreting professors under the supervision of Dr. Abdullah bin Abdul Mohsen Al-Turki 5/194-198, the site of the King Fahd Complex for printing the Holy Quran 5. Interpretation of the Great Koran: Abu al-Fida Ismail ibn Umar ibn Kathir al-Qurashi al-Basri (774 H) Investigator: Muhammad Hussein Shams al-Din Publisher: Dar al-Kutub al-Alamiya, Publications by Muhammad Ali Baydoun - Beirut First Edition - 1419 H 6. : Meanings and manifestations of the Qur'an, author: Ibrahim ibn al-Siri ibn Sahl, Abu Ishaq al-Zajaj (T 311h) Investigator: Abdel Jalil Abdo Shalabi, publisher: World of Books - Beirut Edition: first 1408 H - 1988 AD Secondly, Meton wrote: 7. Malek Ben Anas Bin Malek Bin Amer Al-Asbahi Al-Madani (T 179H) Comment and Investigation: Abdel Wahab Abdel Latif Al-Nashir: The Scientific Library 8. Ibn Abi Shaibah, Abu Bakr ibn Abi Shaibah, Abdullah bin Mohammed bin Ibrahim bin Othman bin Khousti al-Absi (Deceased: 235h), Investigator: Kamal Yusuf al-Hout, Publisher: Al-Rashid Library - Riyadh 9. Musnad Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal Abu Abdullah Ahmad Bin Hanbal Al-Shibani, T:241 A.H., Al-Resala Foundation, 2nd Edition, 1429 A.H./2008 A.D., Investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnout and a group of investigators. 10. Al-Jamaa Al-Musnad Al-Saheem Al-Aksouni Al-Aksyah Al-Aksyah Allah Wa Sallam Sunna Wa Ayama Al-Bukhari, known as Sahih Al-Bukhari, for Muhammad bin Ismail bin Ibrahim bin Mughirah Al-Bukhari, T: 256h, T: Al-Risala Al-Alamiya, first edition, 1432h/2011, Al-Arnawut Investigation, Adel Murshid, and a group of investigators. 11. Correct mosque named Saliha Muslim, by Abu Al-Hussein Muslim bin Al-Hajjaj bin Muslim Al-Qushiri Al-Nishaburi, T:261H, T: Dar Ibn Rajab - Egypt - second edition, 1427H/2006. 12. Sunan Abi Dawud, Abi Dawud Sulayman ibn Ash'ath al-Sijistani, T:275 AH, T: The Library of Knowledge - Riyadh - 2nd Edition, 1427 AH/2007 AD, carefully considered by Mashhur bin Hasan Al Salman. 13. Sanan Al-Tarmadi, Abu Isa Muhammad Bin Isa Al-Tarmadi, T:279H, T: The Library of Knowledge, Riyadh, 2nd Edition, 1429 A.H./2008, with care of Mashhour Bin Hasan Al-Salman. 14. Al-Mustaqbal, Abi Abdallah Al-Hakeem Mohammed Bin Naim Al-Nishaburi, T: 405H, T: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamiya - Beirut, first edition, 1411H/1990. Investigation: Mustafa Abdel Qader Atta. 15. Senior Years: Ahmed Bin Al Hussein Bin Ali Bin Musa Al Khasroujerdi Al Khorasani, Abu Bakr Al Baihaqi (Deceased: 458H) Investigator: Mohamed Abd Al Qader Atta, Publisher: Science Textbook House, Beirut, Lebanon Third: The Conversations: 16. Sahih Al-Bukhari, author: Ibn Batal Abu Al-Hasan Ali Bin Khalaf Bin Abd Al-Malik (dead: 449 A.H.), Investigation: Abu Tamim Yasser Bin Ibrahim, Publishing House: Al-Rashid Library - Saudi Arabia, Riyadh, Edition: II, 1423 A.H. - 2003. 17. Correct Muslim Explanation to Imam Abi Zakariya Mohieddin Yahya Bin Sharaf Al-Nawawi, T: 676H, T: The Conciliation Library-Cairo-Without Edition and Without History, Investigation: Hani Al-Hajj, Imad Zaki Al-Baroudi. 18. Al-Bari opened Sahih Al-Bukhari's explanation to Ahmed bin Ali bin Hajar Abu Al-Fadl Al-Asqalani Al-Shafi'i, Dar Al-Maarafa, Beirut, 1379 A.H., his number of books, doors, and events: Mohammed Fouad Abdul Baqi, directed, corrected, and supervised his edition: Moheb Al-Din Al-Khatib, with the comments of the scholar: Abdul Aziz bin Abdullah bin Baz. 19. Mayor of Al-Qari explained Sahih Al-Bukhari, author: Abu Mohammed Mahmoud Bin Ahmed Bin Musa Bin Ahmed Bin Hussein Al-Geitabi Al-Hanafi Badreddine Al-Aini (Deceased: 855H), publisher: The Arab Heritage Revival House - Beirut 20. The Enlightenment explained the Little Mosque, the author: Muhammad ibn Ismail ibn Salah ibn Muhammad al-Hassani, the Kahlani and then the Sanaani, Abu Ibrahim, Izz ad-Din, known as his predecessors to the Prince (Deceased: 1182H) Investigator: Dr. Muhammad Ishaq Muhammad Ibrahim, the publisher: Dar es Salaam Library, Riyadh, First Edition: 1432H-2011 21. Neil Al-Awtar, Muhammad bin Ali bin Mohammed bin Abdullah Al-Shawkani Al-Yemeni (Dead: 1250 A.H.), Investigation: Essam Al-Din Al-Sababati, Publisher: Dar Al-Hadith, Egypt, First Edition, 1413 A.H.-1993. IV. Asset books and rules 22. Fath al-Qadir, author: Kamal al-Din Muhammad bin Abdul Wahid al-Siwasi, known as Ibn al-Hammam (dead: 861H) Publisher: Dar al-Fikr. 23. Assimilations and Analogies in the Rules and Branches of the Shafi'i Jurisprudence Author: Jalal Al-Din Abdul Rahman Al-Siyuti (T 911 H) Publisher: Scientific Books House First Edition, 1403 H-1983 24. Commentary on the Jurisprudence Rules: Ahmed Bin Al-Sheik Mohamed Al-Zarqa [1285 A.H. - 1357 A.H.] Corrected and commented on: Mustafa Ahmed Al-Zarqa Publisher: Dar Al-Qalam-Damascus/Syria Edition: II, 1409 A.H. - 1989 The Book of Jurisprudence Al-Fiqh al-Hanafi 25. Al-Mabsut to Muhammad bin Ahmed bin Abi Sahl, Shams al-Umaima al-Sarkhsi, T: 483H, T: Dar al-Maarafa, Beirut, no edition, publication date: 1414H/1993. 26. Masterpiece of Jurisprudence: Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Abi Ahmed, Abu Bakr Aladdin Al-Samarqandi (Deceased: 540 A.H., Publisher: Scientific Books House, Beirut, Lebanon, Second Edition, 1414 A.H.-1994). 27. Al-Sanayaa' in the Order of Laws: Aladdin, Abu Bakr Bin Masoud Bin Ahmed Al-Kasani Al-Hanafi, Deceased: 587H, Publisher: Scientific Books Edition: 2, 1406H - 1986 28. Proclamation in the Beginning of the Beginner's Explanation of Abi Al Hassan Burhanuddin Ali Bin Abi Bakr Al Marghinani, T: 593H, T: Dar Al Salam - Cairo - 3rd Edition, 1433H/2012; Investigation of Muhammad Tamer, Assistant Teacher at Dar Ulum College, and Hafez Ashour Hafez. 29. The Burhani Ocean in Omani Jurisprudence is Fiqh Imam Abi Hanifa, the author: Abu Al Maali Burhanuddin Mahmoud Bin Ahmed Bin Abdulaziz Bin Omar Bin Mazza Al Bukhari Al Hanafi (Deceased: 616H) The Investigator: Abdul Karim Sami Al Jundi 30. The choice is to explain the chosen one, the author: Abdullah bin Mahmoud bin Moodoud al-Mosuli al-Baldhi, Majd al-Din Abu al-Fadl al-Hanafi (dead: 683h) 31. Care and demonstration of the gift to Mohammed bin Mohammed bin Mahmoud, Akmal Al-Din ibn Al-Sheik Shams Al-Din Ibn Al-Sheik Jamal Al-Din Al-Rumi Al-Babarti, T: 786 AH, T: Dar Al-Fikr without edition and without history. 32. The building explained the gift to Abu Mohammed Mahmoud bin Ahmed bin Ahmed bin Musa bin Ahmed bin Ahmed bin Hussein Badr Al-Din Al-Hanafi, T: 855H, T: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamiya - Beirut - Lebanon - first edition, 1420H/2000. 33. Al-Muhtar replied to Al-Dur Al-Mukhtar, author: Ibn Abdeen, Muhammad Amin bin Omar bin Abdulaziz Abidin Al-Damashki Al-Hanafi (dead: 1252H), publisher: Dar Al-Fikr-Beirut, second edition, 1412H-1992 Al-Fiqh al-Maliki 34. Indoctrination in Al-Maliki Division, author: Abu Mohammed Abdul Wahab bin Ali bin Nasr al-Thalaabi al-Baghdadi al-Maliki (dead: 422h), investigator: Abu Oweis Mohammed bin Khbaza al-Hassani al-Tatwani, publisher: Dar al-Kutubib al-Alamiya 35. Guidance to the Path of Guidance, author: Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Abi Moussa Al-Sharif, Abu Ali Al-Hashimi Al-Baghdadi (dead: 428H) 36. The Beginning of the Diligent and the End of the Frugal, by Abu al-Waleed Muhammad bin Ahmed bin Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Rashid al-Qurtubi alias Ibn Rushd al-Hafid, T: 595H, T: Dar al-Mughni - Riyadh - 1432H/2011 Ed., Investigation: Muhammad Subhi Hassan Hallaq. 37. Talents of Galil in a brief explanation of Khalil.Author: Shams Eddin Abu Abdallah Mohammed bin Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Trabulsi (Morocco), known as Al-Hattab Al-Maliki (954H)Publisher: Dar Al-Fikr, 3rd edition, 1412H-1992. Al-Fiqh Al-Shafi 38. Mother of Imam Al-Shafi'i, dead 204 A: Dar Al-Wafa - Al-Mansoura - fifth edition, 1429 A.H./2008 A.D.: Dr. Rifaat Fawzi Abd Al-Muttalib. 39. Grand Container of Abu al-Hasan Ali Bin Mohammed Bin Habib al-Basri al-Baghdadi, known as al-Mawardi, T: 450 AH, T: Scientific Books House, Beirut, Lebanon, first edition, 1414 AH/1994 AD, Investigation: Ali Moawad, Adel Abd al-Majud. 40. Statement in the doctrine of Imam Al-Shafi'i, author: Abu Al-Hussein Yahya bin Abi Al-Khair bin Salem Al-Amrani Al-Yemeni Al-Shafi'i (dead: 558h) Investigator: Qasim Muhammad Al-Nouri, publisher: Dar Al-Minhaj - Jeddah, first edition: 1421h - 2000 m 41. Total Explanation of Courtesy, Al-Nuawi, T: Dar Alam Al-Kutub - Riyadh - 2nd Edition, 1427 A.H./2006, achieved, commented on, and completed by the scholar Muhammad Najib Al-Mutai'i. 42. End of the Need to Explain the Curriculum: Shams Al-Din Mohammed Bin Abi Al-Abbas Ahmed Bin Hamza Shihab Al-Din Al-Ramli (T 1004H) Publisher: Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut Edition: A Last Chance - 1404H/1984 Al-Fiqh Al-Hanbali 43. Al-Kafafi fi Fiqh Al-Imam Ahmad, author: Abu Muhammad Muwafaq Al-Din Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Ahmed bin Qudamah Al-Jamaili Al-Maqdisi then Al-Dimashqi Al-Hanbali, alias Ibn Qaddama Al-Maqdisi (Deceased: 620h). 44. Muwafaq Al-Din Abdullah Bin Ahmed Bin Mohammed Bin Qaddama Al-Maqdisi, then Al-Damashki Al-Hanbali, T: 620H, T: Dar Alam Al-Kutub - Riyadh - 8th edition, 1434H/2013, Al-Haqiq: Dr. Abdullah Bin Abdul Muhsin Al-Turki, Dr. Abdel Fattah Mohammed Al-Halu. General Jurisprudence 45. Author: Abu Muhammad Ali bin Ahmed bin Said bin Hazm al-Andalusi al-Qurtubi al-Zahiri (dead: 456H), publisher: Dar al-Fikr - Beirut 46. The Royal Rulings of Abi Ali Al-Furat The book, The Author: Judge Abu Ya'ali, Mohammed Bin Al-Hussein Bin Mohamed Bin Khalaf Ibn Al-Fura (Dead: 458H) Corrected and commented on it: Mohammed Hamid Al-Fiqi, Publisher: Dar Al-Kutukubait Al-Alamiya - Beirut, Lebanon Edition: Second edition, 1421H - 2000 47. Hisba in Islam, or the function of the Islamic government Author: Taqi Al-Din Abu Al-Abbas Ahmed Bin Abd Al-Halim Bin Abd Al-Salam Bin Abd Allah Bin Abi Al-Qasim Bin Muhammad Ibn Taymiyyah Al-Harani Al-Hanbali Al-Damashki (T 728H) Publisher: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alamiya Edition: First edition 48. Grand Fatwas of Ibn Taymiyyah, author: Taqi Al-Din Abu Al-Abbas Ahmad Bin Abd Al-Halim Bin Abd Al-Salam Bin Abi Al-Qasim Bin Muhammad Bin Taymiyyah Al-Hanbali Al-Dimashqi (Deceased: 728H) Publisher: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Alami, First Edition, 1408H-1987. 49. Total Fatwas: Taqi Al-Din Abu Al-Abbas Ahmed bin Abd Al-Halim Al-Harani (Deceased: 728H) Investigator: Abd Al-Rahman bin Muhammad bin Qasim, Publisher: King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran, Prophetic City, Saudi Arabia, Year of Publication: 1416H/1995 50. Government Roads Author: Mohammed bin Abi Bakr bin Ayoub bin Saad Shams Al-Din ibn Qaim Al-Jawziyya (T 751H) Publisher: Dar Al-Bayan Library Edition: No Edition and No Date. 51. Islamic Jurisprudence and Evidence, A. D./Wahba Mustafa Al-Zahaili, T.: Dar Al-Fikr - Damascus - Fourth Edition. Language references, and jurisprudential terminology: 52. Magistrate and the Great Ocean, author: Abul Hassan Ali bin Ismail Bin Sidde El Mursi [T: 458 A.H.], Investigator: Abdel Hamid Hendawi, Publisher: Science Books House, Beirut, first edition, 1421 A.H.-2000 53. Students, author: Omar bin Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Ismail, Abu Hafs, Najm ad-Din al-Nasafi (dead: 537h), publisher: The Umrah Press, Al-Muthanna Library, Baghdad, edition: No edition. 54. Arab tongue of Abu Al-Fadl Jamal Al-Din Muhammad Bin Makram Bin Ali Bin Manzoor, T: 711 A.H., T: Dar Sadir - Beirut, 4th edition, 2005. 55. Moderator, Ibrahim Mustafa, Ahmed Al-Zayyat, Hamid Abdel Qader, Mohammed Al-Najjar, T: Dar Al-Daawa, An Investigation: The Arabic Language Academy. 56. Ambient Dictionary, author: Maged Al-Din Abu Tahir Muhammad Bin Yaqub Al-Firuzabadi (Deceased: 817 H.) 57. Lexicographer Mohamed Rawas Kalaaji - Hamid Sadeq Qunaibi, publisher: Dar Al-Nafis Printing, Publishing and Distribution, second edition, 1408 A.H. - 1988. General references 58. Consumer Protection in Islamic Jurisprudence, Dr. Muhammad Abu Sayid, Dar al-Kutub al-Alamiya - Beirut - Lebanon - first edition 1425 A.H., 2004 . 59. Encyclopedia of the Islamic Economy in Banks, Money and Financial Markets, Dr. Rifaat Al-Awadi, Dar Al-Salam, Cairo - first edition 1431H, 2010 60. Electronic consumer protection in the light of the Consumer Protection Law, the European directives, the French law and the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce, commenting on the latest rulings of the Egyptian and French Court of Cassation and the economic courts, Dr. Kawthar Saeed Adnan Khaled, and Dr. Samiha Mustafa Al-Qalyoubi, the new university's home. 61. The Cartel held a study in Islamic jurisprudence, Dr. Ridha Ahmed Al-Sayed Al-Atawi, on the promotion of a publication at the Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies in Benin-Balddamon-2019. 62. Monopoly and its Contemporary Images Applied Study of Selected Models, Abderrazak Nusrat, Master's Thesis, University of Martyr Hamma Lakhdar-Oued-Algeria. 63. Consumer legal protection between civil law and Islamic jurisprudence, a comparative study, Islam Hashim Abd al-Maqsoud Saad. 64. Competition in Islamic jurisprudence and its impact on the market, by Amal Ahmed Mahmoud Al Hajj Hassan, M.A., National Success University, Algeria. 65. Economic Implications of Harmful Monopolistic Practices, Dr. Shaaban Raafat Mohamed Ibrahim. The Legal Journal (ISSN:2537-0758) 66. Agreements between competitors criminalized by U.S. and Egyptian competition laws are a comparative study of Egyptian and American law. Dr. Ahmed Youssef Mahmoud Bakri, research published in Menoufia University Law School Journal. 67. Economic corruption and its impact on the development of developing countries and mechanisms to combat it from the perspective of the Islamic economy and situation, Dr. Hisham Mustafa al-Jamal, a published research by the Faculty of Sharia and Law in Tanta in 2014.
| ||||
|
Statistics Article View: 858 PDF Download: 424 |
||||
