دور الحشرات في الإثبات الجنائي The Role of Insects in Criminal Evidence

• د. أحمد أبو القاسم، الدليل المادي ودوره في الإثبات في الفقه الجنائي الإسلامي، دراسة مقارنة، رسالة دكتوراه، كلية الحقوق، جامعة الزقازيق، 1990
• د. حاتم أحمد محمد بطيخ: دور الانترنت في الإثبات أمام القاضي الجنائي والإداري، دراسة مقارنة، رسالة دكتوراه جامعة عين شمس، سنة 2017
• د. حسين محمود إبراهيم، النظرية العامة للإثبات الجنائي، رسالة دكتوراه، كلية الحقوق، جامعة القاهرة، 1981،
• د. عبد الحافظ عبد الهادي: القرائن في الإثبات الجنائي، رسالة دكتوراه، أكاديمية الشرطة، القاهرة، سنة 2009
• د. عبد الله بن سعد أبو داسر: إثبات الدعوي الجنائية، دراسة مقارنة، رسالة دكتوراه، جامعة الإمام محمد بن مسعود الإسلامية، المملكة العربية السعودية، سنة 1433، 1434هــ
• د. كمال محمد علي الصغير، الحرية الشخصية للمتهم في إطار نظام الشرعية الإجرائية، دراسة تحليلية تأصيلية، رسالة دكتوراه، كلية الحقوق جامعة القاهرة، 2003.

• بيزار جمال: الدليل العلمي للإثبات الجنائي، رسالة ماجستير بكلية الحقوق والعلوم السياسية، الجزائر، سنة 2014
• خميسي رياض، تأثير أدلة الإثبات الجزائية على الإقناع الشخصي للقاضي في مادة الجنايات، رسالة ماجستير، جامعة العربي بن مهيدي أم البواقي، كلية الحقوق والعلوم السياسية، قسم الحقوق، سنة 2017
• كروم فؤاد، إجراءات المعاينة التقنية لمسرح الجريمة، رسالة ماجستير، كلية الحقوق والعلوم السياسية، قسم الحقوق، جامعة محمد بو ضياف- المسيلة – الجزائر، 2018
• كوثر أحمد خالد: الإثبات الجنائي بالوسائل العلمية، دراسة تحليلية مقارنة، رسالة ماجستير، كلية القانون والسياسة، جامعة صلاح الدين، العراق، 1428هــ
• أبحاث ومقالات:
• د. الهاني محمد طايع رسلان، تقنية بصمة المخ وشرعيتها في الإثبات الجنائي، بحث منشور في مجلة الفكر الشرطي، مركز بحوث الشرطة، مجلد 22، العدد 85، إبريل 2013،
• د. حسن ربيع: دور القاضي الجنائي في الإثبات، بحث منشور بمجلة البحوث القانونية والاقتصادية، كلية الحقوق، بني سويف، جامعة القاهرة، السنة الحادية عشر، يناير سنة 1997
• د. رعد فجر فتيح الراوي: دور علم الحشرات في الإثبات الجنائي، مجلة كلية القانون للعلوم والسياسة، عدد 21 مجلد 6، سنة 2017،
• د. عبد المجيد محمود مطلوب: الأصل براءة المتهم، مجلة المحامي، القاهرة، السنة السادسة، الأعداد (إبريل – مايو – يونية)، سنة 1983
• د. مندي عبد الله محمود حجازي: الحشرات ودورها في الإثبات الجنائي، بحث منشور في مجلة الدراسة، كلية الدراسات الإسلامية والعربية بكفر الشيخ، العدد الخامس، سنة 2015
• د. منصور المعايطة: دور الحشرات في مجال الطب الشرعي والجنائي، جامعة نايف العربية للعلوم الأمنية، مجلد 20، عدد 222
• د. ندى عبد الله محمود حجازي: الحرات ودورها في الإثبات من منظور الفقه الإسلامي، دراسة مقارنة، مجلة الدراية كلية الدراسات الإسلامية والعربية بنين، دسوق
• د. نرمين أحمد زكي: مقال بعنوان الحشرات والتحقيق الجنائي، يوليو 2020،
• د. نضال ياسين الحاج، مبدأ اقتناع القاضي الجنائي، دراسة تحليلية تأصيلية، مجلة كلية القانون للعلوم القانونية والسياسية، جامعة كركوك، مجلد 6، عدد 22، أغسطس 2017.

ثانياً: مراجع باللغة الأجنبية:

• مراجع باللغة الإنجليزية:
• Al- Simary, M.B.J., The Role of Myiasis insects in determining the animal’s death period, M.Sc. Biology, Basrah university, 2013.
• AL-Mesbah, H. A., A study of forensically Important Necrophagous Diptra in Kuwait, Master SC. In Forensic Entomology, University of Central Lancashire, 2010.
• Amendt J, Richards CS, Campobasso CP, Zehner R, Hall MJ. Forensic entomology: applications and limitations. Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2011
• Arnaldos M.I., Garcia m.D., Estimation of post mortem interval in real cases based on experimentally obtained entomological evidence, forensic science international, 2005
• Arti Prasad, Forensic Entomology: Role of Insects as Crime Indicators, penwi-21 conference, August 2022, Mohan Lal Sukhadia University
• Benecke M., Forensic Entomology: Arthropods and Corpses. Int Tsokos M (ed) Forensic Path Rev, Vol.11, Humana Press, Totowa, (NJ, USA), 2004.
• Bonacci, T., Vercillo, V. and Benecke, M., Dermestes frischii and D. undulateus (Coleoptera:Dermestidae) on a human corpse in southern Italy: First report, Rom. J Legal Med. 2017
• Byrd, J.H., and Castner, J.L., Forensic Entomology, the utility of Arthropods in Legal Investigation, Second Edition, CRC Press, Boca Raton, USA, 2010
• Byrd, J.H., and Castner, J.L., Insects of Forensic Importance in Forensic Entomology, 2009
• Carloye, L. "Of Maggots and Murder: Forensic Entomology in the Classroom" The American Biology Teacher, Vol 65, 2003.
• Carvalho, C.J.B.D. and Mello-Patiu , C.A.D., Key to The Adults of The Most Common Forensic Species of Diptera in South America, Revista Brasileira de Entomologia, 2008
• Catts, E. P., Entomology and Death, a procedural guide. Clemson, SC: Joyce’s Print Shop, 2000
• Catts, E.P. and Goff, M.L. 1992. Forensic Entomology in Criminal Investigations, Annual Review of Entomology,
• Centeno N., Seasonal Patterns of Arthropods occurring on sheltered and unsheltered Pig Carcasses in Bueno Aires Province (Argentina), Forensic Science International.
• Compobasso, C.P., Marchetti D., Introna, F. and Colonna, M.F., Postmortem Artifacts Made By Ants And The Effect Of Ant Activity On Decompositional Rates, Am. J. Forensic Med Pathol. 2009
• Dorothy E. Gennard, Forensic Entomology: An Introduction, John Wiley & Sons, The Atrium, West Sussex, England, 2007
• Dorothy E. Gennard, Forensic Entomology: An Introduction, Lincoln University, UK, translated by Prof. Nazar M. Al-Mallah, 2016
• Dr Andrew J. Hart, The Use of Forensic Entomology in Criminal Investigations: How it can be of benefit to SIOs, The Journal of Homicide And Major Incident Investigation, Volume 4, Issue 1 Spring 2008
• Eberhard Josephi, Neglect of the elderly: forensic entomology cases and considerations, Forensic Science International 146S (2004)
• Erzinclioglu, Z., Maggots, Murder and Men: Memories and Reflection of a Forensic Entomologist, Harley Books, Great Horkesley, (Colchester, UK), 2000,
• Feddern, N., The Importance of Saprinus Semistriatus (Coleoptera:Histeridae) for Estimating the minimum post-Mortem interval, Legal Medicine, 2018
• Gaudry E. Eight Squadrons for onr target: the Fauna of cadaver described by P. Megnin, Proceedings of the first European forensic Seminar,77eafe.orgLOISIN_2002,
• Gennard, D., Forensic Entomology: an introduction, John Wiley &Sons,2012
• Gennard, D.E. 2007, Forensic Entomology: an introduction. John Wiley and Sons, Ltd, university of Lincoln, UK
• Goff, M L., 2000. A Fly for the Prosecution: How Insect Evidence Helps Solve Crimes. Cambridge: Harvard University Press
• M.L., Forensic Entomology In Criminal Investigations , AmlU. Rev. Enlomol. 1992 .
• Greenberg B., and Kunich J.C., Entomology and the Law: Flies as Forensic indicators, Cambridge University Press, 2002
• Haskell, N.H., and Williams, R.E. 2008, Entomology and Death: A Procedural guide 2nd ed. Clemson, SC: Joyce’s Print Shop
• Dekeirsschieter, C. Frederickx, F. J. Verheggen, P. Boxho, And E. Haubruge, Forensic Entomology Investigations From Doctor Marcel Leclercq (1924–2008): A Review of Cases From 1969 to 2005, Journal Of Medical Entomology, Vol 50
• Johnnie Erskine, How do Entomologists use insects to determine PMI, University of Nebraska – Lincoln, 2018.
• Kevin C Daly, Explosives detection with hard-wired moths, une 2003Conference Record - IEEE Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference 2(4):1669 - 1672 vol.2
• Klaus Gottlieb, The Mincemeat Postmortem: Forensic Aspects of World War II's Boldest Counterintelligence Operation, February 2009, Article in Military Medicine vol.174
• Manisha A. Sardar, A Comprehensive Overview of Forensic Entomology, Int J Eth Trauma Victimology, 2021
• Mark Benecke, A Brief Survey of the History of Forensic Entomology, Acta Biologica Benrodis 14. 2008
• Mark Benecke, Six Forensic Entomology Cases: Description and Commentary, Journal of Forensic Sciences, 1997
• Matthias Gosselin, Entomotoxicology, experimental set-up and interpretation for forensic toxicologist ,May 2011, Forensic Science International 208
• Mohamed A. Kenawy, Yousrya M. Abdel-Hamid, Medico-Legal Forensic Entomology "Use of Insects in Death Investigations"- A Review , Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences , Vol.11(2), (2019)
• Mohammed Rafeq Ali, Ahmad M. Tariq and Batool Abdul Jabbar Hussein, Forensic entomology in the disclosure of the circumstances of criminal cases: a review, science Archives (2020) Vol. 1 (3)
• Monika, Gayatri Gujar, Forensic entomology: Insects as evidence, Journal of Entomology and Zoology Studies 2020
• Musvaska E., Preliminary observation on the effects of Hydrocortisone and sodium Methohexital on development of Sarcophaga Tibialis Macquart, and implications for estimating post mortem interval, Forensic science international, 2001,
• Padonou, G.G., First Evidence of Forensic Entomology revealed the Presence of arthropods on rabbit carrion in Cotonou Benin ( west Africa) INT.J. Entomol
• Raju, A. Appala. "Forensic Entomology- Insects Role in Criminal and Civil Laws." International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences(2019): n. pag.
• Richard W. Merritt, Forensic Entomology, Michigan State University, Ch 69, 2004
• Russell Mizell, Forensic Entomology, textbook، youth development department, university of Florida, 2011
• Ramesh Babu, Forensic Entomology: A Novel Approach for Crime Investigation, Indian Journal of Agriculture and Allied Science
• Sharkey MJ. 2004. Afrotropical - North American disjunct distribution of Minanga (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) with the description of a new species and first record for the New World. Annals of the Entomological Society of America 97
• Soham Mitesh Vakil, THE ROLE OF INSECTS IN A CRIME SCENE FORENSIC SCIENCE, journal of forensic justice, Vol.1, issue 1, July, 2022,
• Subhra Priyadarshani, Investigators are Increasingly Using Maggots to Solve Crimes, The Telegraph (9th October, 2006).
• Swift B., Methods of time since death estimation within early post-mortem interval, the journal of homicide and Major incident investigation, 2010, Vol. 6,
• K.P., Mouraa M.O. and De Mello- Patiub. C.A. 2015, Comparative Morphology, and identification key for females of nine Sarcophagidae Species (Diptera) with forensic importance in Southern Brazil
• Vass, A. A., Beyound the Grave: understanding human decomposition, Microbiology Today, 2001
• Wall R., Daily temperature fluctuation and the accumulation of day ,degres, Proceedings of the European Association for Forensic Entomology، 2004, London.
• Yu Wang, Guoliang Hu, Forensic entomology application in China: Four case reports, Article in The Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine · March 2019
• مراجع باللغة الفرنسية:
• Alexandra Milhat , comment sur les insects relevant l heure du crime? .Article puplie en 2/10/2019
• Alexandre Beaudoin et Daniel Guillementte ,Scene De crime, Guide complet pour les policiers, editions andre fontaine, 2014 ,p(2-8)
• Celine Morin, Les experts des scenes de crime ,Article puplie le 10 juin 2021 ,mis a jour le 3 fevrier 2023,
• Cristine Frederic , Jessica Dekeirsschieter, Francois J, Eric Hauburge, Lentmoologie forensique, les insects resolvent les crimes, Entomologie faunistique .2010-2011
• Cristine Lazerges, La presumption d innocence en Europe, Archirve de politique criminelle, 2004/1 (N 26),
• Cyrielle Friedrich ,les procedures accusatoire, inquisitoire, mixte et l administration de la prevue ,Article  publie 7 juin 2017 , https //: acromand – avocet
• Damien Charabize , Etude de la biologie des insects necrophages et application a l expertise en entomologie medico – legal, these , universite de Lille 2, 2008
• Francois Daoust, sur les traces de la police technique et scientifique ,chapter 3 ,De la scene de crime, 2020
• Gaudry E., Charabidze D & Gosselin, M. (2014) Conclusion et perspectives en entomologie forensique. In Insectes, Cadavres et scènes de crime ; Principes et applications de l’entomologie médico-légale, Ed. De Boeck
• Jean Philippe , l entomologie au service de l agriculture (Agriculture ,Pecheries et Alimentation), 26 mars 2015
• Michael Visibilite et Samuel Tanner, Policiere a l ere de la sousveillance, Filmer et etre filme , Dan Reseaux,2017

Romain Garrouste, Salman Shayya, Scene de crime: quand les insects mement L enquete , Article, puplie ,mars 21, 2018

References:

• d. 'abu aleala 'abu aleula alnamiru: aljadid fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, ta1, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahirati, 2000
• d. 'abu aleula alnamiru: al'adilat aljinayiyat fi daw' alfiqh wa'ahkam alnaqd aljanayiyi, dirasat tahliliat lildalil aljinayiyi fqhaan wemlaan, dar alsadaqat lilnashr waltawziei, sanat 1991
• da. 'ahmad 'iibrahim: turuq al'iithbat alshareiati, matbaeat alqahirat alhadithat liltibaeati, alqahirati, misr, sa35, bidun sanat nashira,
• da. 'ahmad saed muhamad rashid. alwajiz fi masrah aljarimat wal'adilat almadiyati. bidun dar nushr bidun sanat nashr
• d. 'ahmad dya' aldiyn muhamad khalil, mashrueiat aldalil fi almawadi aljinayiyat dirasat tahlilih muqaranatan linazariati al'iithbat walmashrueiat fi majal al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, alqahirat, bidun dar nashr, 2005
• da. 'ahmad fathi srur: alwasit fi qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, dar alnahdat alearabiati, sanat 2012
• d. adm wuhayb alnadawi: sharh qanun al'iithbati, ta2, matbaeat dar alqadisiat al'aezamiat, baghdad, sanat 1986,
• du. alsayid muhamad hasan sharif, alnazariat aleamat lil'athabat aljanayiy, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahirati, bidun sanat nashra,
• d. 'amal mustafaa ramzi shirba, qanun albayinati, aljumhuriat alearabiat alsuwriati, jamieat alshaam alkhasati, kuliyat alhuquq
• d. 'ayman faruq eabd almaebud hamd: al'iithbat aljinayiyu bishahadat alshuhud fi alfiqh aljinayiyi al'iislamii walqanun aljinayiyi alwadei, alnaashir maktabat alqanun walaiqtisadi, alrayad, 2012
• d. hasan rabie, dawr alqadi aljinayiyi fi al'iithbat dirasat muqaranati, t 4, alqahirata, dar althaqafati, sanat 1996.
• d. husayn muhamad tah, zaynab mahmud hasan: qarinat aiftirad albara'at wa'atharaha alqanuniat dirasat muqaranati, 2019
• d. hamdi aljasima: 'usul almuhakamat aljazayiyati, matbaeat aleali, sanat 1962
• da. rafat eabd alfataahi: al'iithbat aljinayiyu qawaeidah wa'adlath muqaranatan bialsharieat al'iislamiat dar alnahdat alearabia
• da. ruqayat skil, muhadarat fi madat turuq alathibati, alsanat althaalithat huquq tukhasis alqanun alkhasi, kuliyat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiati, jamieat hasibat bin bu ealaa bialshalaf, alsanat aljamieiat 2019/2020,
• du. saeid hasab allah eabd allah: sharah qanun 'usul almuhakamat aljazayiyati, ta2, dar alhikmat liltibaeat walnashri, 1998
• da. dayf eabd allatif: dawr alhasharat fi altahqiq aljanayiy,
• da. tariq 'iibrahim aldasuqi eatiat, masrah aljarimat fi daw' alqawaeid al'iijrayiyat wal'asalib alfaniyati, dar aljamieat aljadidati, 2012
• d. tah mutawali: altahqiq aljinayiyu wifq aistintaq masrah aljarimati, bidun dar nashra, sanat 2000
• d. eabd alhakim fudat: hajiat aldalil alfaniyi fi almawadi aljinayiyat walmadaniati, dar alfikr aljamieii, al'iiskandaria
• d. eabd alhamid almulayhi, nizam alathibat aljinayiyi fi altashrie almaghribii walmuqarani, dar nashr almaerifati, sa26, bidun sanat nashr
• d. eabd alrazaaq alsanhuri: alwasit fi sharh alqanun almadanii aljadida, dar alnahdat alearabiati, aljuz' althaani, sanatan 1968.
• alwsit fi sharh alqanun almadanii, nazariat alailtizam biwajh eami, al'iithbati, athar alailtizami, almujalad althaani, bidun sanat nashr
• d. eabd alhadi eabd alhafiz eabir: al'iithbat aljinayiyu bialqarayini, dar alnahdat alearabiati, ta1, sanat 1996
• d. euthmani eabd alkarim bin litirsh, manhajiat 'akhdh eayinat min masrah aljarimat lilbahth ean albasmat alwirathiati, 'ashghal almultaqaa alwatanii hawl altibi alshareii alqadayiyi alwaqie wal'afaq
• d. eismat eabd almajid bakr: sharah qanun al'iithbati, dar alsinhurii alqanuniat waleulum alsiyasiati, 2018,
• da. eimad muhamad 'ahmad rabiei: hijiat alshahadat fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, ta1, maktabat dar althaqafat lilnashr waltawziei, eaman, al'urduni, sanat 1999
• da. fadil zidan muhamad, sultat alqadi aljinayiyi fi taqdir al'adilati, dar althaqafat lilnashr waltawziei, eaman, 2005
• d. fuad eabd almuneim 'ahmadu: albasmat alwirathiat wadawruha fi al'iithbat aljinayiyi bayn alsharieat walqanuni, almaktabat almisriati, al'iiskandiriati, sanat 2012
• d. kamal bin sadiq yasin: 'ahkam alhasharat fi alfiqh al'iislamii, maktabat alrushdi, nashirun almamlakat alearabiat alsueudiat - alrayad, ta1, 1428h, 2007m
• d. mamun salamat: qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyat muealiqan ealayh bialfiqh wa'ahkam alnaqdu, dar alfikr alearabii, 1980
• al'iijra'at aljinayiyat fi altashrie almisrii, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahiratu, sanat 1996,
• d. muhamad hamaad alhiti, almawsueat aljinayiyat fi albahth waltahqiq aljanayiy, al'adilat aljinayiyat almadiyatu, alzumrat lilnashri, 2008,
• d. muhamad sayid hasan muhamad, dawabit sultat alqadi aljinayiyi fi taqdir al'adilati, dar alnahdat alearabiati, alqahirat ,2002,
• d. muhamad eabd allatifi: qanun al'iithbat fi almawadi almadaniat waltijariati, alqahirati, sanat 1970,
• d. muhamad eid alghirib, huriyat alqadi aljinayiyi fi aliaqtinae alyaqinii wa'atharuh fi tasbib alaihkam aljinayiyati, bidun dar nashri, sanat 19961997,
• d. muhamad fuaad tawfiq: eilm alhasharat aleami, dar alzahra' - alrayad, ta6, sanat 1428h
• d. muhamad lutfi eabd alfataahi, alqanun aljinayiyu wastikhdamat altiknulujya alhayawiati, t 1, dar alfikr walqanun lilnashr waltawzie, almansurati, 2012
• d. mahmud sayid 'ahmad eabd alqadir: al'iitar alqanunia litatwir nuzm altaqadi watakwin mabda alaiqtinae alqadayiy, sanat 2020
• d. mahmud tah: sharh qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, aljuz' althaani, alfasl fi aldaeawii aljinayiyati, sanat 2013
• d. mahmud muhamad suif: dawr basmat almukhi fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, dar aljamieat aljadidati, 2022
• d. mahmud najib hasni, sharh qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, dar alnahdat alearabiati, t 3, 1995
• qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, dar alnahdat alearabiati, 1992
• d. muruk nasr aldiyn: muhadarat fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, alnazariat aleamat lil'iithbati, aljuz' al'uwala, dar hawmati, aljazayar, 2009,
• d. mustafi mahmud mahmud: sharah qanun al'iijra'at aljinayiyati, matbaeat jamieat alqahirat walkutaab aljamieii, sanat 1988
• d. muejab mieadi alhwyqla: dawr aldalil almadiyi fi al'iithbat aljinayiy, 'akadimiat nayif lileulum al'amniati, alrayad, sanatan 1999
• d. hisham eabd alhamid faraja, mueayanat masrah aljarimati, bidun dar nashra, sanat 2007
• mueayanat masrah aljarimat li'aeda' alqada' walniyabat aleamat walmuhamaat walshurtat waltibi alshareii, altabeat al'uwlaa, bidun dar nashr, 2004,
• da. walid eabd alghani kaekatu, eilm alhasharat aljanayiy, taruq alkashf ean aljarayim fi altahqiqat alqanuniati, muasasat alkuayt liltaqadum aleilmii lilnashr waltawziei,2011.

alrasayil aleilmiia:

rasayil aldukturah:

• d. 'ahmad 'abu alqasima, aldalil almadiyu wadawruh fi al'iithbat fi alfiqh aljinayiyi al'iislamii, dirasat muqaranati, risalat dukturah, kuliyat alhuquqi, jamieat alzaqaziq, 1990
• du. hatim 'ahmad muhamad batikh: dawr alaintirniti fi al'iithbat 'amam alqadi aljinayiyi wal'iidari, dirasat muqaranati, risalat dukturah jamieat eayn shams, sanatan 2017
• d. husayn mahmud 'iibrahim, alnazariat aleamat lil'iithbat aljanayiy, risalat dukturah, kuliyat alhuquqi, jamieat alqahirati, 1981,
• d. eabd alhafiz eabd alhadi: alqarayin fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, risalat dukturah, 'akadimiat alshurtat, alqahirat, sanat 2009
• d. eabd allah bin saed 'abu dasir: 'iithbat aldaeawii aljinayiyatu, dirasat muqaranati, risalat dukturah, jamieat al'iimam muhamad bin maseud al'iislamiati, almamlakat alearabiat alsueudiati, sanat 1433, 1434h
• d. kamal muhamad eali alsaghir, alhuriyat alshakhsiat lilmutaham fi 'iitar nizam alshareiat al'iijrayiyati, dirasat tahliliatan tasiliati, risalat dukturah, kuliyat alhuquq jamieat alqahirati, 2003.

rasayil almajistir:

• bizar jamali: aldalil aleilmii lil'iithbat aljanayiy, risalat majistir bikuliat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiati, aljazayar, sanat 2014
• khamisi riad, tathir 'adilat al'iithbat aljazayiyat ealaa al'iiqnae alshakhsii lilqadi fi madat aljinayati, risalat majstir, jamieat alearabii bin mahidi 'am albawaqi, kuliyat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiati, qism alhuquqi, sanat 2017
• krum fuad, 'iijra'at almueayanat altaqniat limasrah aljarimati, risalat majistir, kuliyat alhuquq waleulum alsiyasiati, qism alhuquqi, jamieat muhamad bu dayafi- almasilat - aljazayar, 2018
• kuthar 'ahmad khalid: al'iithbat aljinayiyu bialwasayil aleilmiati, dirasat tahliliat muqaranata, risalat majistir, kuliyat alqanun walsiyasati, jamieat salah aldiyn, aleiraq, 1428h

'abhath wamaqalat:

• d. alhani muhamad tayie raslan, tiqniat basmat almukh washareiatuha fi al'iithbat aljinayiyi, bahath manshur fi majalat alfikr alshurti, markaz buhuth alshurtat, mujalad 22, aleadad 85, 'iibril 2013,
• d. hasan rabie: dawr alqadi aljinayiyi fi al'iithbati, bahath manshur bimajalat albuhuth alqanuniat walaiqtisadiati, kuliyat alhuquqi, buni suif, jamieat alqahirati, alsanat alhadiat eashr, yanayir sanatan 1997
• d. raed fajr fatih alraawy: dawr eilm alhasharat fi al'iithbat aljanayiy, majalat kuliyat alqanun lileulum walsiyasati, eadad 21 mujalad 6, sanat 2017,
• d. eabd almajid mahmud matluba: al'asl bara'at almutahami, majalat almuhami, alqahirati, alsanat alsaadisati, al'aedad ('iibril - mayu - yunia), sanat 1983
• d. mandi eabd allah mahmud hijazi: alhasharat wadawruha fi al'iithbat aljinayiy, bahath manshur fi majalat aldirasati, kuliyat aldirasat al'iislamiat walearabiat bikufr alshaykhi, aleadad alkhamisi, sanat 2015
• du. mansur almueayatati: dawr alhasharat fi majal altibi alshareii waljanayiy, jamieat nayif alearabiat lileulum al'amniati, mujalad 20, eadad 222
• du. nadaa eabd allah mahmud hijazi: alhuraat wadawraha fi al'iithbat min manzur alfiqh al'iislamii, dirasat muqaranati, majalat aldirayat kuliyat aldirasat al'iislamiat walearabiat binin, dasuq
• du. nirmin 'ahmad zaki: maqal bieunwan alhasharat waltahqiq aljanayiya, yuliu 2020,
• du. nidal yasin alhaji, mabda aiqtinae alqadi aljinayiyi, dirasat tahliliat tasiliatun, majalat kuliyat alqanun lileulum alqanuniat walsiyasiati, jamieat karkuka, mujalad 6, eadad 22, 'aghustus 2017.