THE POSSIBLE PROTECTIVE ROLE OF N-ACETYLCYSTEINE AGAINST TRAMADOL- INDUCED NEPHROTOXICITY IN THE ADULT ALBINO RATS (LIGHT AND ELECTRON MICROSCOPIC STUDY) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Al-Azhar Medical Journal | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Volume 52, Issue 4, October 2023, Page 1005-1024 PDF (679.45 K) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Document Type: Original Article | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
DOI: 10.21608/amj.2023.326108 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
View on SCiNiTO | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Authors | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Abd El-Aziz Mohammed Abo-Youssef ; Ahmed Mostafa Kamal; Wahed Yousre Mohammed Abd El-Aziz | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Anatomy Department, Faculty of Medicine, Al-Azhar University, Cairo | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Abstract | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Background: Tramadol is nephrotoxic in over doses N-acetylcysteine is effective against inflammatory processes and oxidative stress. Objective: Study of tramadol- induced nephrotoxicity on the rats and assess the possible protection of N-acetylcysteine. Material and Methods: Forty adult albino rats were obtained from the breading animal house of Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University. The rats were housed in the animal house at Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University under the suitable and standard conditions of temperature and feeding from January, 2021 till February, 2021. The rats were divided into four groups Group I (control group): the rats of this group was given 30 ml /kg saline daily for thirty days orally; group II (treated with tramadol): the rats of this group were given l5.5 mg /kg tramadol orally daily for thirty days; Group III (Toxic dose tramadol): The rats of this group were given 30 mg /kg tramadol orally daily for thirty days; Group IV (treated with toxic dose of tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine): The rats of this group were given 30 mg /kg tramadol and N-acetylcysteine 100 mg/kg orally daily for thirty days. The rats at the last day of the experiment were killed and their kidneys were collected for histological evaluation using hematoxylin and eosin and Masson trichrome, and examined under light and transmission electron microscope. Also, Blood samples were taken for measurement of urea and creatinine. The data obtained from biochemical results for all groups were expressed as means and subjected to statistical analysis. Results: Treatment of rats with toxic dose of tramadol (group III) showed marked damage in the renal tissues, The damage in the renal tissues was improved in rats that were given N- acetylcysteine together with tramadol (group IV). However, tramadol that was given in a therapeutic dose (Group II) did not cause any damage in the kidney. Conclusion: N-acetylcysteine partially improves the tramadol –induced nephrotoxicity. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Keywords | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Tramadol; N-acetyl cysteine; Oxidative stress and nephrotoxicity | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Full Text | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
THE POSSIBLE PROTECTIVE ROLE OF N-ACETYLCYSTEINE AGAINST TRAMADOL- INDUCED NEPHROTOXICITY IN THE ADULT ALBINO RATS (LIGHT AND ELECTRON MICROSCOPIC STUDY) By Abd El-Aziz Mohammed Abo-Youssef, Ahmed Mostafa Kamal and Wahed Yousre Mohammed Abd El-Aziz Anatomy Department, Faculty of Medicine, Al-Azhar University, Cairo Corresponding author: Abd El-Aziz Mohammed Abo-Youssef Mobile: 01095354506; E-mail: drabdulazizmoh25@gmail.com ABSTRACT Background: Tramadol is nephrotoxic in over doses N-acetylcysteine is effective against inflammatory processes and oxidative stress. Objective: Study of tramadol- induced nephrotoxicity on the rats and assess the possible protection of N-acetylcysteine. Material and Methods: Forty adult albino rats were obtained from the breading animal house of Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University. The rats were housed in the animal house at Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University under the suitable and standard conditions of temperature and feeding from January, 2021 till February, 2021. The rats were divided into four groups Group I (control group): the rats of this group was given 30 ml /kg saline daily for thirty days orally; group II (treated with tramadol): the rats of this group were given l5.5 mg /kg tramadol orally daily for thirty days; Group III (Toxic dose tramadol): The rats of this group were given 30 mg /kg tramadol orally daily for thirty days; Group IV (treated with toxic dose of tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine): The rats of this group were given 30 mg /kg tramadol and N-acetylcysteine 100 mg/kg orally daily for thirty days. The rats at the last day of the experiment were killed and their kidneys were collected for histological evaluation using hematoxylin and eosin and Masson trichrome, and examined under light and transmission electron microscope. Also, Blood samples were taken for measurement of urea and creatinine. The data obtained from biochemical results for all groups were expressed as means and subjected to statistical analysis. Results: Treatment of rats with toxic dose of tramadol (group III) showed marked damage in the renal tissues, The damage in the renal tissues was improved in rats that were given N- acetylcysteine together with tramadol (group IV). However, tramadol that was given in a therapeutic dose (Group II) did not cause any damage in the kidney. Conclusion: N-acetylcysteine partially improves the tramadol –induced nephrotoxicity. Keywords: Tramadol; N-acetyl cysteine; Oxidative stress and nephrotoxicity.
INTRODUCTION Tramadol is considered a centrally acting analgesic. It is wide spreadly used throughout the world. It has opioid, nor adrenergic and serotonergic properties. Various data suggest that, in addition to its analgesic effect, tramadol may have also antidepressant and anxiolytic-like effects (Berrocoso et al., 2011). Tramadol produces its analgesic property via the inhibition of reuptakes of both serotonin and nor-epinephrine (Reeves and Burke, 2011). The liver is the main site of the metabolism of tramadol. The products of the metabolism are excreted via the kidney, so the kidney is the main target for the toxicity of tramadol. Biotransformation of tramadol occurs in the liver, firstly by demethylation of tramadol and then conjugation of the demethylated compounds occur resulting in about ten metabolites (Dickman, 2012). Repeated tramadol administration might lead to accumulation of toxic metabolites, increase the risk for pharmacokinetics interactions and/or decrease the clearance of tramadol, thus increasing its potential for toxicity (Senay et al., 2011). Oxidative stress is considered the major damaging process resulting from the imbalance between the reactive oxygen species (which have been produced in an excess manner) and decreased antioxidant defences (Turrens, 2013). These reactive oxygen species (such as H2O2, O2− and CO3− ), which produced in an excess manner, cause much damage in DNA and also produce harmful effects in cell membranes via lipid peroxidation (Droge, 2012). N-acetyl cysteine (NAC) is an n-acetylated derivative of the naturally occurring amino acid cysteine (Gass and Olive, 2013). It is a synthetic precursor of glutathione (GSH), which can stimulate the intracellular synthesis of GSH and enhances glutathione S-transferase (GST) activity (Tylicki et al., 2015). It is highly effective in the intracellular neutralization of free radicles (Aruoma et al., 2015; Harrison et al., 2010). AIM OF THE WORK The aim of this work was to demonstrate the various toxic effects by tramadol abuse on the renal cortex and also to study if N- acetyl cysteine has a rule in improvement of these dangerous toxic effects and protect the kidney from nephrotoxicity. MATERIAL AND METHODS І. Material: Animals: The present study was performed on forty adult albino rats of 4-6 months old. The rats weighed 200 - 250 gm each in average. They were obtained from the breading animal house of Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University. Under the suitable and standard conditions of temperature and feeding, the rats were housed in the animal house at Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University from 15th Jan., 2021 till 14th Feb., 2021. Drugs: "Tamol –X" is the commercial form of tramadol hydrochloride, containing 225 mg of tramadol hydrochloride and obtained from the Royal National Pharmaceutical Company. Tramadol was used at a dose of 15.5 mg /kg body weight orally by intra gastric tube every day for one month in the therapeutic dose group (Group II) (Subedi et al., 2018; Nair & Jacob, 2016) and in a dose of 30 mg/kg body weight orally by intra gastric tube every day for one month in the toxic dose group (Group III) (Matthiesen et al., 2010). N-acetyl cysteine 100 mg/ 5 ml was obtained in the form of "Solvimyst" which is the commercially used syrup of N- acetyl cysteine and obtained from Menapharm Company for Pharmaceutical and Chemical Industries. N- acetyl cysteine was used at a dose of 100 mg/kg body weight orally by intra gastric tube every day for one month (Adikwu & Bokolo, 2017; Borgström et al., 2014). Experimental design: The rats were divided into four groups equally as follows: Group (I) (Control group): A normal saline in a dose of 30 ml /kg body weight was given to the rats of this group every day for thirty days orally via the intra gastric tube. Group (II) (Tramadol - treated group) (Therapeutic dose group): Tramadol hydrochloride was given to the rats of this group in a dose of 15.5 mg /kg body weight and given orally via the intra gastric tube every day for thirty days (Subedi et al., 2018; Nair & Jacob, 2016). Group (III) (Tramadol - treated group) (Overdose group): The rats of this group were given also tramadol hydrochloride but in a higher dose than that in group II. The dose was 30 mg /kg body weight which was given orally via the intra gastric tube daily for thirty days (Matthiesen et al., 2010). Group (IV) (Tramadol - N-acetyl cysteine treated group): The rats of this group were given tramadol Hydrochloride in a dose of 30 mg/kg body weight and N-acetyl cysteine in a dose of 100 mg/kg body weight orally via the intra gastric tube every day for thirty days (Adikwu & Bokolo, 2017; Borgström et al., 2014). At the end of the experiment, inhalation of ether was used to anesthetize the rats, then the rats were sacrificed and the kidneys were extracted carefully.
For examination by the light microscope, samples from the kidneys were taken from each kidney and cut into small pieces (about 2-4 mm3), put in 10 % formaldehyde (for 24 hours) for fixation and then proceeded to be embedded in paraffin wax, sectioned at 5 microns thin sections and were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H& E) and Masson's trichrome (MT) stains and then examined under light microscope. For examination by the electron microscope, small pieces (about 1mm3) were obtained from the cortices of each kidney, put in 2.5% glutaraldehyde for fixation (for 45 min), and then prepared for embedding in epon resin. The ultrathin sections of (50 nm) thickness was obtained and mounted on grids of copper and stained with lead citrate and uranyl acetate. The examination of the sections was carried out by using a transmission electron microscope. Photomicrographs were taken to detect the ultra-structure of the kidneys.
RESULTS
Light microscopic findings:
Sections stained with Massonʼs trichrome stain revealed few collagen fibers with normal distribution among the glomerular capillaries and in the interstitium Figures (2A & 2B).
Sections stained with Massonʼs trichrome stain showed increased collagen fibers among the glomerular capillaries and in the interstitium as compared to the control group Figure (2C).
Sections stained with Massonʼs trichrome stain showed incomplete recovery in the form of focal areas with moderate amount of collagen fibers in the interstitium Figure (2D). Electron microscopic findings:
Figure (3): An electron photomicrograph of the renal cortex of adult albino rats of the group I showing: A) A part of a glomerulus showing regular basement membrane (red arrow), average podocytes (P) with average foot processes (blue arrow) and patent filtration slits (yellow arrow) and average endothelial cells (white arrow) (TEM x10000). B) A part of a proximal convoluted tubule showing cells with basally located euchromatic nucleus (N) and prominent nucleolus (red arrow), numerous mitochondria (blue arrow), dense long microvilli (yellow arrow) and average basal lamina (white arrow). (TEM x 10000). C) A part of a distal convoluted tubule showing cells with few short microvilli (red arrow), rounded centrally located nuclei (N) with central nucleoli (blue arrow) and condensed chromatin in the periphery (yellow arrow) and numerous mitochondria (white arrow) (TEM x 5000).
Figure (5): An electron photomicrograph of the renal cortex of adult albino rats of the group III showing: A) A part of a glomerulus showing thick irregular basement membrane (red arrow), podocytes (P) with rarefied cytoplasm, thick (blue arrow), fused foot processes (yellow arrow) and narrow filtration slits (white arrow) and dilated capillaries (C). B) A part of a proximal convoluted tubule showing cells with markedly pyknotic nuclei (N) with intra-nuclear inclusion bodies (red arrow) and clumped chromatin in the periphery (green arrow), scattered swollen mitochondria (blue arrows), many cytoplasmic vacuoles (yellow arrows) and destructed basal lamina (white arrow). C) A part of a distal convoluted tubule showing cells with round centrally located nuclei (N) with clumped chromatin in the periphery (red arrow), numerous mitochondria (blue arrow) within irregular basal infoldings (white arrow), irregular basal lamina (black arrow) and marked cytoplasmic edema (yellow arrow) (TEM x 10000).
The sera of blood samples were taken from the rats of all groups at the end of their experimental period then sent to Royal Lab Tanta for analysis of urea and creatinine. The data were compared to the normal levels of urea and creatinine of the control group (group I). The two parameters were increased significantly in rats of group III while they came toward the normal range in group IV. In group II the results were within normal range. These data have been summarized in tables 1-2 and graphics 1-2.
Table (1): Comparison between the mean values of creatinine in the different studied groups (groups I, II, III, IV) using analysis of variance (ANOVA) test.
Table (2): Comparison between the mean values of urea in the different studied groups (groups I, II, III, IV) using analysis of variance (ANOVA) test.
Graph. (2): Comparison between the mean values of urea in the different studied groups (group I, II, III, IV).
Interpretation of Statistical analysis: Statistical analysis of the biochemical results using one way ANOVA (analysis of variance) test showed a statistically significant difference in tramadol treated (over dose) group (group III) (p value <0.05 was significant) as compared with control group (group I) and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) group (group II). On the other hand, our findings showed no statistically significant difference detected in the control group (group I) and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) group (group II). Also, our results revealed no statistically significant difference detected in the tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine treated group (group IV) as compared with the control group (group I).
DISCUSSION N-acetyl cysteine (NAC) is a small molecule that can be freely filtered, with easy access to intracellular compartments and is very effective in neutralizing free radicals (oxidents) intra-cellularely (Aruoma et al., 2015; Harrison et al., 2010). Studies have implicated oxidative stress as one of the possible mechanisms of drug-induced renal toxicity (Santos et al., 2014). Hence, antioxidants (e.g. N-Acetyl cysteine) could have potential as treatment for drug-induced renal toxicity (e.g. Tramadol). In the current work, examination of haematoxylin and eosin-stained sections from the control and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) groups revealed that the renal cortex was formed of numerous renal corpuscles and renal tubules with normal interstitium containing peritubular capillaries. Each renal corpuscle consisted of a glomerulus containing tuft of capillaries and surrounded by visceral and parietal layers of Bowmanʼs capsule which were separated by Bowmanʼs space. These results were in accordance with what was reported by previous studies (Rao et al., 2011). They added that the inner visceral layer of Bowmanʼs capsule was formed of highly differentiated cells called podocytes. The cortical renal tubules were formed mainly of proximal and distal convoluted tubules. They were lined with simple cuboidal epithelium with central rounded nuclei. The luminae of the proximal tubules were irregular and narrower than the distal ones. Similar results were reported by previous studies (Ross and Pawlina, 2011). In the present study, the histological picture of tramadol treated (over dose) group showed various degrees of renal cortex affection. Focal areas were observed containing renal corpuscles with congested glomerular capillaries and irregular parietal layer of Bowmanʼs capsule. These results were in concomitant with that reported by other studies (Awadalla and Salah eldin, 2015) who attributed the congested glomerular capillaries and more extensive changes in the form of atrophied glomeruli, wide urinary space and degenerated proximal and distal convoluted tubules to the pro-oxidant effects of the tramadol over dose. In agreement with other studies (Abd El-aal et al., 2016), some tubular cells had small pyknotic nuclei while others had intracellular vacuolations. Granular hyaline casts in the lumen of some tubules and abnormal dilatation of others were also seen. In accordance with other studies (Masini et al., 2012), tramadol over dose may induce apoptosis in many cell types. In the current work, tramadol over dose induced histological picture of acute renal failure in the form of small sized (shrunken) glomeruli, degeneration and swelling of the renal tubular cells with necrotic nuclei. Tubular dilatation and intraluminal casts were also observed. These results were in accordance with other studies (Sayed and Zidan, 2016). Toxic ffects of tramadol over dose also were explained by previous studies that found that these toxic effects resulted from tramadol-induced lipid peroxidation of renal tissues. Lipid peroxidation of cell membranes leads to loss of membrane fluidity, changes in membrane potential and an increase in membrane permeability, all of which leads to alteration of the chemical compounds of the cells (Masini et al., 2012). In the current work, examination of the haematoxylin and eosin stained sections from tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine treated group revealed nearly normal histological structure of the renal corpuscles. These results were in agreement with other studies (Aldini et al., 2018). In the present study, Massonʼs trichrome stained sections of the control and tramadol (therapeutic dose) treated groups clarified the presence of few collagen fibers in the renal cortex distributed among glomerular capillaries and in the interstitium. Compared to the control group, tramadol over dose administration in group III caused an increase in the collagen fibers in the renal cortex distributed among the glomerular capillaries and the interstitium. On the other hand, Massonʼs trichrome stained sections of tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine-treated group revealed few collagen fibers among the glomerular capillaries and the interstitium denoting partial recovery. In the current work, electron microscope examination of ultrathin sections of the renal cortex of the control and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) groups showed normal glomerular blood capillaries with average endothelial cells. The glomerular basement membrane appeared regular. Podocytes were also noticed with average foot processes and patent filtration slits. These results were in concomitant with other studies (Tryggvason and Wartiovaara, 2011). Proximal tubular cells were seen with rounded euchromatic nucleus and closely-packed microvilli. Numerous mitochondria and average basal lamina were also seen. These results were in agreement with previous studies (Figueiredo et al., 2018) who illustrated that the microvilli of the proximal tubule cells provide a large extensive surface area for unidirectional transport of solutes from the lumen to blood. The lining epithelial cells of the distal convoluted tubules appeared with few short microvilli, rounded centrally located nuclei with central nucleoli and numerous mitochondria which seen scattered in the cytoplasm. These results were in coinciding with other studies (Zhai et al., 2016). In the present work, ultrathin sections from the renal cortex of tramadol (over dose) treated group showed dilated glomerular capillaries with irregular basement membrane and distorted foot processes of the podocytes. Proximal convoluted tubular cells contained pyknotic nuclei with intra-nuclear inclusion bodies. Numerous swollen mitochondria, irregular and destructed basal lamina and multiple cytoplasmic vacuoles were also observed. The distal tubular cells appeared with rounded centrally located nuclei with clumped chromatin in the periphery. Numerous mitochondria were seen within irregular basal infoldings. Irregular basal lamina and cytoplasmic edema were also observed. These results were in agreement with other studies (Ali et al., 2015) who also reported these results. In the present study, ultrathin sections from the renal cortex of adult male albino rats of the tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine-treated group demonstrated the renal corpuscle containing normal glomerular blood capillaries with regular basement membrane. Podocytes were also seen with average foot processes. Tubular cells containing normal euchromatic nuclei and numerous normal mitochondria were also seen. Normal microvilli appeared at the apical cell membrane of the proximal tubular cells. Statistical analysis of the biochemical results using one way ANOVA (analysis of variance) test illustrated a statistically significant difference in tramadol treated (over dose) group (group III) (p value <0.05 was significant) as compared with control group (group I) and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) group (group II). On the other hand, our findings demonstrated no statistically significant difference detected in the control group (group I) and tramadol treated (therapeutic dose) group (group II). Also, our results exposed no statistically significant difference detected in the tramadol and N-acetyl cysteine treated group (group IV) as compared with the control group (group I). CONCLUSION The results of this study clarified that tramadol, when used in over doses causes histological changes in the renal cortex. However, these changes did not present when tramadol was used in low doses. Also, these changes slightly decreased with N-acetyl cysteine usage. We recommend that renal investigations should be routinely done with tramadol treatment or tramadol abuse. We should be causious with tramadol a demonstration in patients with renal impairment. REFERENCES
الدور الوقائي المحتمل لــ" ان-اسيتيل سيستايين" علي التسمم الكلوي المحدث بالترامادول في الفئران البيضاء البالغه (دراسه بالميكروسكوب الضوئي والالكتروني) عبد العزيز محمد ابويوسف، احمد مصطفي كمال، وحيد يسري محمد عبد العزيز قسم التشريح والاجنه، كلية طب، جامعة الازهر (القاهره) E-mail: drabdulazizmoh25@gmail.com المقدمه: يعد دواء الترامادول من المسكنات الصناعيه التي تعمل مركزيا علي المخ و يستخدم بشكل واسع في علاج الالام المعتدله الي الشديده والالام الحاده والمزمنه كما يعتبر تأثيرعقار الترامادول كمسكن مشابه لتأثير عقار الكودايين وعشر مرات اقل من تأثير عقار المورفين. ويعتبر عقار ان-اسيتيل سيستايين مشتق من الحمض الاميني سيستايين وهو لديه عدة خصائص كمضاد للأكسده والألتهابات، وقد تم استخدامه في ابحاث اجريت من قبل علي انسجة الكبد، وقد تبين ان اعطاءه يؤدي الي تحسين الانسجه التالفه. الهدف من البحث: الهدف من هذا البحث هو دراسة هستولوجيه باستخدام الميكروسكوب الضوئي والاكتروني النافذ لبيان التأثيرات السامه لعقار الترامادول علي انسجة الكلية وايضا دراسة الدور الوقائي المحتمل لعقار ان-اسيتيل سيستايين ضد هذه التاثيرات. الطرق والأدوات المستخدمه في هذا البحث: قد تم استخدام أربعين من الفئران البيضاء البالغه وتم تقسيم هذه الفئران الي اربع مجموعات متساويه كالأتي: المجموعه الأولي: تمثل هذه المجموعه المجموعه الضابطه وقد تم اعطائها محلول ملح بجرعة 30 مجم /كجم عن طريق انبوبة المعدة يوميا لمدة ثلاثين يوما. المجموعة الثانية: اعطيت هذه المجموعه كلوريد الترامادول بجرعه دوائيه تقدر ب 15.5 مجم/كجم عن طريق انبوبة المعدة يوميا لمدة ثلاثين يوما. المجموعة الثالثه: تم اعطاء هذه المجموعه كلوريد الترامادول بجرعةعالية (سامة) تقدر ب 30 مجم / كجم عن طريق انبوبة المعدة يوميا لمدة ثلاثين يوما. المجموعه الرابعه: تم اعطاء هذه المجموعه كلوريد الترامادول بجرعة عاليه (سامه) تقدر ب 30 مجم / كجم بالاضافه الي عقار ان-اسيتيل سيستايين بجرعة تقدر ب 100 مجم/كجم عن طريق انبوبة المعدة يوميا لمدة ثلاثين يوما. بعد انتهاء المده المحدده تم تخدير الفئران باستنشاق الاثير واستئصلت الكلي منها ثم تم تحضيرها للفحص بالميكروسكوب الضوئي و الميكروسكوب الاكتروني النافذ، وخضعت النتائج للدراسات التحليليه والاحصائيه. النتائج: قد اثبتت القطاعات التي صورت بالميكروسكوب الضوئي والالكتروني النافذ النتائج التاليه:
4.بالنسبه للعينات التي عولجت بجرعات عاليه من الترامادول واضيف اليها عقار ان-اسيتيل سيستايين (المجموعه الرابعه) فقد اظهرت الدراسات الهستولوجيه ان :
وعلي مستوي الميكروسكوب الالكتروني النافذ فقد وجد الاتي :
خلاصة نتائج البحث: استخدام الترامادول بجرعة عاليه (سامة ) يؤدي الي الحاق الضرر البالغ في القشرة الكلويه مع توسع ملحوظ في الانابيب واضافة ان-اسيتيل سيستايين حسنت جزئيا من هذه الاثار السامه، في حين ان استخدام الترامادول بجرعة عادية (دوائيه) لا يحدث هذه التاثيرات السامه، لذا نوصي بمتابعة وظائف الكليه للمريض الذي يتناول عقار الترامادول بجرعات عاليه لفترات طويله بشكل دوري، كما يمنع استخدام الترامادول في مرضي الفشل الكلوي. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
References | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
REFERENCES
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Statistics Article View: 149 PDF Download: 124 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||